DR
Dibakar Roy
Apr 26, 2026
I visited Roop Chicago expecting a memorable experience, especially given its Michelin association but unfortunately, it fell far short.
We opted for the tasting menu, hoping for a thoughtfully curated journey through flavors. Instead, it turned out to be one of the most disappointing tasting menu experiences I’ve had. The courses lacked cohesion, and many dishes leaned heavily toward sweetness, which threw off the balance you would expect in Indian cuisine. Rather than highlighting creativity, the “fusion” approach felt forced and poorly executed. If you truly enjoy authentic Indian food, this is not the place for either taste or hospitality. In the name of “fusion,” the flavors feel overly altered and, in many cases, simply unpleasant.
We started with the pani puri, which was a major disappointment. The puris were soggy and lacked flavor entirely. We tried lamb kebab and hara bhara kabab, and neither dish impressed and overall, the flavors felt unbalanced and poorly executed. Even simple things like properly serving biryani weren’t handled well. The “Old Delhi” course featuring butter paneer or butter chicken, felt overly sweet and one-dimensional, missing the richness and balance these classic dishes are known for. Desserts under “Sweet Notes” and “The End” continued the same trend, visually appealing, but lacking depth in flavor. By that point, the excessive sweetness throughout the meal had already become overwhelming.
Service was another letdown. Our server, while polite, was clearly juggling too many tables, which significantly slowed down the entire experience. What should have been a refined dining experience stretched to nearly 3.5 hours. For comparison, I have had tasting menu experiences in California that were completed smoothly within 2 hours without feeling rushed.
There were also two other staff members possibly a manager or owner whose attitude fell short. They did not come across as welcoming or attentive, which added to the overall sense that customer experience was not a priority. In fact, the server’s attitude ended up being the most positive part of the service, which says a lot.
The pricing is also quite high, which makes the overall experience even harder to justify. There are many better Indian restaurants in Chicago that offer both better food and service at a more reasonable price.
It was also confusing to see Michelin branding displayed at the front without clarity on whether it is a Michelin Star or just a Michelin Guide listing—it creates expectations that the experience simply doesn’t meet.
Overall, while the presentation of the dishes was appealing, the food lacked depth, balance, and authenticity. Between the disappointing flavors, underwhelming service, extended wait times, and high cost, this was a poor experience.
I would strongly recommend choosing another Indian restaurant in Chicago instead.