Free Nutella
$49.99
Get 2 Sharing Cheese Pizzas and get Free Nutella
Brand Certified
PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO
4.7(412 reviews)
Certified by PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO • Jul 05, 2026
Business Details
2459 N Halsted St, Chicago, IL
60614, United States
Certified by PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO • Jul 05, 2026
(312) 800-1600
Certified by PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO • Jul 05, 2026
https://properpizzachicago.com
Certified by PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO • Jul 05, 2026
About
Certified by PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO • Jul 05, 2026
Pizza Restaurant
Details
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Curbside pickupAvailable
Location
Certified by PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO • Jul 05, 2026
Hours
Certified by PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO • Jul 05, 2026
Monday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Tuesday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Wednesday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Thursday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Friday11:00 AM - 2:00 AM
Saturday11:00 AM - 2:00 AM
Sunday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Menu
1 menu · 88 items
Explore offerings from PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO on 2459 N Halsted St in Chicago, with popular holiday special, individual pizza (12), sharing pizza (16), and party pizza (24) available at this location.
Full Menu
88 items
Individual Pizza (12)
1. Margherita (12)
$16.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sesame seeds.
2. Mushroom Pizza (12)
$18.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mushrooms, sesame seeds.
3. OMG Vegetarian (12)
$19.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mixed peppers, zucchini, caramelized onions, eggplants, onions, sesame seeds.
4. BBQ Chicken (12)
$20.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken, bbq sauce, and sesame seeds.
5. Pepperoni (12)
$19.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pepperoni, sesame seeds.
6. Tuna (12)
$22.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, tuna fish, sesame seeds.
8. Anchovies (12)
$22.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, anchovies, olives, sesame seeds.
9. Proper Pizza (12)
$23.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, smoked beef prosciutto, smoked beef sausage, mushrooms, and sesame seeds.
10. Blues Brother (12)
$25.00
Tomato sauce, 5 ingredients of your choice, sesame seeds.
11. Sausage Pizza (12)
$23.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sausage, sesame seeds
12. 4 Cheese (12)
$24.00
White sauce, special proper cheese, gorgonzola, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, sesame seeds,
13. Hawaiian (12)
$24.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pineapple, ham, and sesame seeds.
14. Crudo Parmesan (12)
$25.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, rucola, parma ham prosciutto, sliced parmesan, cherry tomato, and sesame seeds.
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, ham, sliced black olives, onions, mixed peppers, mushrooms, loca sauce, sesame seeds.
16. Macho (12)
$21.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken meatballs, macho sauce, chives, sesame seeds.
17. Truffle (12)
$25.00
White sauce, truffle paste, truffle oil, mushrooms, pecorino cheese, pine nuts, sesame seeds.
18. Cheeseburger (12)
$24.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, meatballs, iceberg lettuce, burger sauce, ketchup, chives, and sesame seeds.
19. Buffalo Chicken (12)
$20.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, buffalo chicken, and sesame seeds.
0. Cheese Pizza (12)
$14.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sesame seeds.
Sharing Pizza (16)
1. Margherita (16)
$22.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sesame seeds.
2. Mushroom Pizza (16)
$25.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mushrooms, sesame seeds.
3. OMG Vegetarian (16)
$26.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mixed peppers, zucchini, caramelized onions, eggplants, onions, sesame seeds. .
4. BBQ Chicken (16)
$28.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken, bbq sauce, and sesame seeds.
5. Pepperoni (16)
$28.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pepperoni, sesame seeds.
6. Tuna (16)
$32.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, tuna fish, sesame seeds.
8. Anchovies (16)
$32.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, anchovies, olives, sesame seeds.
9. Proper Pizza (16)
$34.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, smoked beef prosciutto, smoked beef sausage, mushrooms, and sesame seeds.
10. Blues Brother (16)
$35.00
Tomato sauce, 5 ingredients of your choice, sesame seeds.
11. Sausage Pizza (16)
$29.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sausage, sesame seeds
12. 4 Cheese (16)
$29.00
White sauce, special proper cheese, gorgonzola, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, sesame seeds,
13. Hawaiian (16)
$29.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pineapple, ham, and sesame seeds.
14. Crudo Parmesan (16)
$29.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, rucola, parma ham prosciutto, sliced parmesan, cherry tomato, and sesame seeds.
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, ham, sliced black olives, onions, mixed peppers, mushrooms, loca sauce, sesame seeds.
16. Macho (16)
$28.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken meatballs, macho sauce, chives, and sesame seeds.
17. Truffle (16)
$35.00
White sauce, truffle paste, truffle oil, mushrooms, pecorino cheese, pine nuts, sesame seeds.
18. Cheeseburger (16)
$34.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, meatballs, iceberg lettuce, burger sauce, ketchup, chives, and sesame seeds.
19. Buffalo Chicken (16)
$28.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, buffalo chicken, and sesame seeds.
0. Cheese Pizza (16)
$20.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sesame seeds.
Free Nutella
$49.99
Get 2 Sharing Cheese Pizzas and get Free Nutella
Party Pizza (24)
1. Margherita (24)
$40.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sesame seeds.
2. Mushroom Pizza (24)
$42.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mushrooms, sesame seeds.
3. OMG Vegetarian (24)
$44.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mixed peppers, zucchini, caramelized onions, eggplants, onions, sesame seeds.
4. BBQ Chicken (24)
$45.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken, bbq sauce, and sesame seeds.
5. Pepperoni (24)
$46.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pepperoni, sesame seeds.
6. Tuna (24)
$45.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, tuna fish, sesame seeds.
8. Anchovies (24)
$48.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, anchovies, olives, sesame seeds.
9. Proper Pizza (24)
$48.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, smoked beef prosciutto, smoked beef sausage, mushrooms, and sesame seeds.
10. Blues Brother (24)
$48.00
Tomato sauce, 5 ingredients of your choice, sesame seeds.
11. Sausage Pizza (24)
$42.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sausage, sesame seeds
12. 4 Cheese (24)
$43.00
White sauce, special proper cheese, gorgonzola, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, sesame seeds,
13. Hawaiian (24)
$45.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pineapple, ham, and sesame seeds.
14. Crudo Parmesan (24)
$48.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, rucola, parma ham prosciutto, sliced parmesan, cherry tomato, and sesame seeds.
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, ham, sliced black olives, onions, mixed peppers, mushrooms, loca sauce, sesame seeds.
16. Macho (24)
$43.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken meatballs, macho sauce, chives, and sesame seeds.
17. Truffle (24)
$46.00
White sauce, truffle paste, truffle oil, mushrooms, pecorino cheese, pine nuts, sesame seeds.
18. Cheeseburger (24)
$48.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, meatballs, iceberg lettuce, burger sauce, ketchup, chives, and sesame seeds.
19. Buffalo Chicken (24)
$45.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, buffalo chicken, and sesame seeds.
0. Cheese Pizza (24)
$38.00
Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sesame seeds.
Sides
A cross between garlic bread and pizza, cheesy bread is a quick, easy, and delicious party snack, with macho sauce.
Crisp romaine tossed with croutons, Caesar dressing, grated cheese, and Chicken
Caesar Salad
$12.99
Crisp romaine tossed with croutons, Caesar dressing, and grated cheese
Macho Sauce
$1.00
Loca Sauce
$1.00
Ranch Sauce
$1.00
Caesar Sauce
$1.00
Slice Pizza
$5.49
Chicken Wings
$9.90
Fresh jumbo wings seasoned with our spices, served plain or tossed in buffalo or BBQ sauce with a choice of dressing
Chicken Tenders
$11.99
6 Fresh Chicken tenders with a choice of flavor and dressing sauce
Baby Arugula Salad
$10.99
Arugula Salad with Extra virgin olive oil, Balsamic vinegar, Sweet Balsamic, Cherry tomato, Pine nuts, and shaved Parmesan Cheese
Soft Drinks
Coca Cola
$2.00
Coca Cola Zero
$2.00
Sparkling Water
$2.99
Natural Water
$2.00
Red Bull
$3.99
2L Soda
$4.99
Diet Coke
$2.00
Sprite
$2.00
Espresso
$2.50
Espresso
Americano Caffè
$2.50
Americano Caffe
Macchiato Caffe
$2.75
Macchiato Caffe
Sweet Corner
Crunchy Nutella
$19.99
Nutella, Caramel, Granulated Peanuts, Graham Cracker Crumbs, and a pinch of Love
Vegan Pizza
Cheese Vegan (12)
$21.99
Tomato sauce, vegan mozzarella cheese, sesame seeds.
Vegan Veggie (12)
$23.99
Tomato sauce, vegan vitalite mozzarella cheese, mixed peppers, zucchini, eggplants, onions, and sesame seeds.
Reviews
4.7
412 reviews
5 stars
357
4 stars
13
3 stars
13
2 stars
12
1 star
17
- BBBrett3 days ago5.0Although there was barely any tomato sauce on the pizza slice, this was still a pretty great late night spot for some interesting pizza. Since it is run by middle easterners the the bread crust is very high quality and tastes different from other pizza. They have pizza by the slice ($6) but only with select toppings. Overall I would try it out ~
- SESahar EJun 27, 20265.0Friendly staff, quick service, and great pizza.
- MDMaria DJun 6, 20265.0They have the best pizza ever!!! The have the best service ever and best people ever!!!
- AJAshley Renée JohnsonMay 16, 20262.0Service was great, friendly, fine. The issue is the pizza: totally not proper. We visited around 5 pm and the place was nearly empty. The margherita pizza didn't have fresh basil as listed. And the mushroom pizza was made with soggy, canned mushrooms, meh. The pizzas were so greasy (too much cheese) and undercooked. I did like the sesame seed crust, but not worth it otherwise.
- KRKevin RoofMay 16, 20262.0I can't believe the rating this place has. Canned mushrooms, canned. No basil on the margherita, soggy undercooked crust. We ate two slices and walked to another restaurant. The sesame seeds were the only redeeming quality. Improper pizza.
Frequently Asked Questions About PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO
What are the regular opening hours of PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO?
PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO is open from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM Monday through Thursday and on Sunday. On Fridays and Saturdays, it stays open later, until 2:00 AM.
Does PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO offer delivery and takeout services?
Yes, PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO offers both in-store pickup and delivery services for customer convenience.
Where is PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO located?
PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO is located at 2459 N Halsted St, Chicago, IL 60614, USA.
What is the price range at PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO?
The price range at PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO is considered moderate, rated as TWO on the price scale.
How can I view the menu and place an order at PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO?
You can view the menu and place orders online by visiting their menu page at https://properpizzachicago.com/menu.
What kind of restaurant is PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO?
PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO is a versatile restaurant offering pizza, Italian, American, vegetarian, vegan, and family dining options, along with catering services.
Are there any popular eateries near PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO?
Yes, nearby popular eateries include Proper Pizza, Noodles In The Pot (Thai restaurant), Paula’s Thai Kitchen, Taj Mahal (Indian restaurant), and Parson’s Chicken & Fish, offering diverse dining choices before or after visiting PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO.
What nearby entertainment venues can visitors check out near PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO?
Visitors can enjoy live music and nightlife at nearby venues such as Golden Dagger, B.L.U.E.S., and Blues On Halsted, which are great options for entertainment after dining.
Are there any wellness and spa services near PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO?
Yes, there are several nearby wellness options including Leah Chavie Skin Care Boutique, Lincoln Park Med Spa, Lincoln Square Skin Care, SkinMuva Beaute, and RevitTx All Natural Solutions, providing beauty and medical spa services.
What are the contact details for PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO?
You can contact PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO by phone at +1 312-800-1600 or visit their official website at https://properpizzachicago.com.
Brand Certified Facts from PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO
This information is certified by PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified July 05, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website