Prince Street Pizza

Reviews

• JW

  John Webb

  6 days ago
  5.0
  This place is awesome! The naughty pie is incredible and is, correctly, highly recommended. The staff is great, classic pizza NY atmosphere, clean inside, and it comes quick by the slice. Will definitely be returning!
• NS

  narmeen shehadi

  Jul 4, 2026
  5.0
  My favorite pizza place ever!!! I love the staff so much they’re so kind & always giving. Yesterday I went in and Deckers took my order he was so kind & sweet along with all the guys in the back!! I recommend this place to anyone looking for good service & good pizza!!
• MI

  Muhammad Isa

  Jul 3, 2026
  1.0
  I’ve order online twice from them and both times I’ve order a pizza with beef pepperoni. Both times I’ve received a plane cheese pizza that looks like it’s been sitting around a while. Horrible service.
• SO

  Sarah O'Donnell

  Jul 2, 2026
  3.0
  Unfortunate. The workers provided half our order and questioned how they should know what we ordered (missed 70% of it). I could not imagine having to tell someone what I ordered directly after ordering and paying for it. Then they question you and being baffled.
• EN

  Elton Nguyen

  Jun 13, 2026
  2.0
  I’m giving 2 stars since the pizza was good, but the low rating is basically for the service while waiting for my pizza. I went at 10pm on Friday (which was packed) so I definitely understood that I would have to wait when I ordered a pie and was told 20 minutes. However, I am writing this review solely based on the fact that there was a group of teenagers that were probably 10 people behind me that also ordered 8 slices (basically a pie) of the same thing I ordered and got theirs in 2 minutes because they were chatty with the workers. On top of it, after 35 minutes (after those teenagers are gone), the worker suddenly decides to acknowledge me and ask for my name again. And then after that my pizza arrives in less than 5 minutes. I wouldn’t have ever said anything, but the fact that they pick and choose to make me wait but have a pizza ready for the someone else just because they are have a conversation puts a bad taste in my mouth. I definitely would have came back but now I’ll be avoiding this place when I need a pizza unless this is a last resort.

Frequently Asked Questions About Prince Street Pizza