KH
Kirsten hill
Sep 27, 2026
Natalie was our waitress last night for dinner. She was so kind, so attentive and such a happy girl. We just loved her. Food was great as always!!
DP
Dawn Priestley
Sep 19, 2026
We had a large group, so service was erratic; they could have organized better. They ran out of preferred vegetable. Loved the "bread" - essentially a raspberry tart.
KJ
Kelsey Jonas
Sep 18, 2026
Took about 3 minutes for anyone to notice we were in the restaurant. Once we got seated it took about 10 minutes for us to ask someone if we could get our drink order in. The raspberry twist was delicious. My omelette would have been good but the onions and green peppers were completely raw. I tried to eat it and not complain but it was so not enjoyable. They only took a percentage off the omelette. The hash browns also weren’t cooked very long.
DC
Doug Corbett
Aug 29, 2026
Excellent choice for delicious food, and the staff is super kind and competent. Burgers are the go-to choice here. They have little Signs, “butter your buns at Butterburr’s”.
The fries are delicious, they have several options, including curly fries, straight fries, beer, battered fries, as well as more traditional, comfort, food like mashed potatoes, green beans, steak and shrimp. All of it was delicious! Would highly recommend this place to anyone looking for good food, or a nice relaxed atmosphere for conversation. They do not have televisions in the restaurant area, which is nice for conversing. There is a small bar as well.
In other notes, they have a family bathroom as well as one for each gender. Overall, I give this place five stars! Would recommend it to anyone going through Pocatello as a must visit spot, and anyone who lives in Pocatello should visit to say you’ve tried their food! It won’t disappoint!!
TD
Tyler J. Carlin (DividedStory)
Aug 27, 2026
I came to this Renowned Pocatello Restaurant by recommendation from a personal friend... My waitress didn't really hurry to my table, it came across as just because I'm one person my tip wouldn't be that big so others were given priority.
The host got my drink order immediately and when the waitress finally acknowledged me it wasn't a "hi my name is" or a "welcome to ButterBurr's" I was asked "are you ready to order?" The non-introduction kinda sucked, and it only stung after reading the amazing story they included about the OG owners on their menu about their legacy.
Once I got my food, the chicken fried steak wasn't that good unfortunately but, the FRESH mashed potatoes WITH SKIN was amazing and their gravy was delectable too. The green beans were probably from a 'can' but I get it, things are expensive. The bread choices were unique but I went with a scone and I gotta say I was pleasantly surprised they made the scones fresh instead of frozen goods.
I'd visit again easily but, I'd order something else besides the Chicken Fried Steak.