Pizza Counter

Reviews

• JC

  Jake C.

  Jun 25, 2026
  5.0
  Very affordable and VERY good. My wife and I had personal pizzas. She had mushroom and I had BBQ which was excellent.
• KK

  Kate Kuszynski

  Jun 5, 2026
  5.0
  My first time at the Pizza Counter was at the Bike's 100, AC/DC tribute bike night in May 2026. My friend had a few too many drinks and needed some food to sober up. We decided on The Pizza Counter because we had seen others with their boxes and it smelled so good passing by that we had to try it. We walked in and looked at a menu. My friend was a bit rude and impatient as she was so hungry and only had a liquid lunch. Embarrassed by her behavior, I expected a annoyed employee ignoring our attempt to order. Instead I got the opposite. I apologized for her impatient demands, but the owner himself took our order as if we were old friends. We didn't know it was 5 minutes to close, but they took our order and I ushered my friend outside to wait for our pizza. Being from a food service background, I know it sucks when only a few minutes until you lock the doors on a busy block party night, some rude people walk in wanting a pizza, so we tipped them well! Don't forget to tip, people depend on your generosity! When the pizza was ready, the owner walked the pizza outside to us and made sure we had plates and napkins so we could share with the rest of our crew. The pizza was hot, guey, and delicious!! The toppings were ample, unlike other places, and was expertly crafted making every bite balanced. Just the right amount of sauce, cheese, toppings and crust in each slice. I usually have a whole bunch of crust left over with other places, but not this Pizza! It is obvious that each Pizza Counter pizza is made with love and care. It was hands down the best pizza I have had in a long time. Before we got back to the party we chatted with the owner about the live music and block party. He let us know that every month they will have another bike night event, so look for Bikes 100 on Facebook for future dates. And please visit Pizza Counter for great service and awesome pizza!!! Thank you to the staff and owner for your hospitality and outstanding pizza!!!
• ZZ

  ZEE ZEE

  May 7, 2026
  5.0
  There is such a difference in fresh ingredients and this place has it all. The dough is fresh and cooked through, resulting in a crust that is in no way flabby. The crust can hold its own with any toppings put on it. The toppings were fresh and made me feel like why am I going anywhere else to get pizza? The service was attentive and very cordial. I haven’t had everything on the menu yet but I’ll be happily enjoying every step I take to get to that goal!
• LH

  Lisa W Hoult

  Mar 3, 2026
  1.0
  I've had several very decent experiences here till the other night. Ordered a Special for takeout and requested a swap of sausage for Canadian bacon. It was ready when I got there, but upon arriving home, I discovered no meat, other than beef and pepperoni. The beef was plentiful, the pepperoni was very minimal (MAYBE 1 or two pieces per slice) and no Canadian bacon. Mushrooms coverage was decent, black olives and onions were barely present. Not much in the way of sauce and the taste was terribly bland. It's so bad, I can't enjoy the leftovers, either. Such a disappointment, especially since they're most convenient. $30 wasted. Back to the King where consistency is a staple.
• CC

  Caleb

  Feb 6, 2026
  5.0
  Walked in and asked if they where open . It was right at 9pm so walked in. You could tell they where cleaning up and just about finished. They still where so willing to serve us. Great people. The meat pockets are out if this world good. They could of turned us away . Very polite and willing to cook.

Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza Counter