Small Town Pastry Cafe

Reviews

• KF

  Kyra Findlay

  Sep 25, 2026
  3.0
  I heard so many good things and I really really wanted to love this place, but it honestly misses the mark. Every single item I got was very obviously not fresh, and was definitely stale/old. I’m sure that the pastries are a lot better fresh, but that wasn’t the experience I had. The fruit mousse was most disappointing, and at a whopping $11 a piece, don’t bother. The pumpkin almond croissant was better and had a really nice flavor but still definitely stale. The biggest ouch, though, is that I went today (Friday 09/25/26) when they’ve been posting all week that they had a buy 2 get 1 free promo, and that was not honored at checkout, which really sucks considering how disappointing the items were themselves. All in all, it’s all a good concept, but the execution, at least today, was lackluster.
• CR

  Casey Rasmussen

  Sep 5, 2026
  5.0
  A cute little shop with a varied selection of beautiful and tastey looking pastries. I got a personal sized strawberry cheese cake and a chicken ceazar wrap. Both were good. Staff was nice and attentive. It was a nice place to have lunch on a Saturday, would recomend.
• KM

  KayJay Medina

  Aug 19, 2026
  2.0
  Would be great if staff would address you and take your order. They were all busy in the back chatting. Looked out at me waiting at the counter and said nothing.
• CC

  CG

  Aug 17, 2026
  3.0
  My pastry was really good. It was stuffed with pistachio filling and very tasty, so I didn’t mind the price for that, but the burritos are definitely overpriced. The service wasn’t the best either. I asked a worker if she had any salsa for my burrito and she told me she’d be right back, and she never came back. I asked another worker if I could have salsa and he answered seemingly annoyed that they only had salsa packets and were behind me. Most likely won’t come back.
• RW

  rochelle wierima

  Jul 24, 2026
  5.0
  Love this bakery so much!! Been going for years and everything is delicious. Recently ordered a cake for my daughter’s birthday and it was soooo delicious and moist!! We will only order our cakes from there moving forward. Highly recommend!!