Donatello's The Urban Trattoria

Reviews

• WD

  Whitney DeRosa

  Sep 24, 2026
  5.0
  Really cool interior and great food! Our kids loved the kids pizza experience where they got to make their own pizza. We also got the chicken parmesan and a pizza with burrata on it. Both delicious!
• SW

  Sara Welch

  Sep 18, 2026
  5.0
  Food was absolutely outstanding! We had three different entrees and loved all three! We got the cheese pizza for my 3 year old and my husband (who is from New York) said that it was the best pizza hes ever had in the state of Georgia!
• RP

  Renzo Gavino | Real Estate Professional

  Sep 16, 2026
  5.0
  Found a real gem in Winder.💎 We had the Al Quattro Formaggi and the Chicken Pesto, and both were outstanding. Rich, fresh, clearly made with care. As a local broker I am always telling people what makes this area worth moving to, and Donatello's is going straight on that list. Great food, warm atmosphere, genuinely local. The music can get a bit loud at times, but nothing to serious.
• DP

  Duane Puckett

  Sep 14, 2026
  3.0
  We've now dined multiple times at both your Winder restaurants and enjoyed service and food at Donatellos and Tacos n Social. Evening of Aug 29 we gave take-out a try while enjoying live music just around the corner at Finished Goods Brewery, and have to say, it was very disappointing. Calamari (which we have ordered before and enjoyed) was bottom of the fryer basket pieces/crumbs, barely warm and maybe half the normal portion, and our Ai Funghi Misti failed to even make the to go delivery bag. Called the reataurant immediately (maybe 10pm, very near closing) and spoke with a member of your team, she apologized, acknowledged the Funghi did not make the order and she would issue $17 credit. As of today, over 2 weeks, no credit has been issued. Also communicated on this same platform in a written comment next day....again to date, no response from any team member at Donatellos. Long story short...a restaurant we had enjoyed made a mistake, didnt meet expectations for a take out order very near close time.....honestly thats not a problem, but it does become a problem when you fail to acknowledge and accept responsibility. Restaurant business is tough, we trust this experience isn't typical.
• BB

  Brooke Busbee

  Sep 8, 2026
  3.0
  The service was good, and everyone was nice, but the menu is a little overpriced for what’s offered. The pasta sauces tasted good, but the overall dishes weren’t the quality we expected for the price point. My husband and I went for a date night, and it was nice to experience once, but we were surprised to see a “Large Party Gratuity” added to our bill. It was 20%, which is what we would have tipped our server anyway, but we thought it was weird to add a Large Party Gratuity to a party of two.