Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• KL

  Kentucky limousine

  4 days ago
  5.0
  I’ve got to say, Johnny’s Pizza absolutely nailed it! We ordered a large hamburger and pepperoni pizza and asked them to bake it extra crispy, and it came out absolutely excellent. The crust was perfectly crispy without being burnt, the cheese was melted just right, and there was a great amount of hamburger and pepperoni on every slice. You could tell it was fresh, hot, and made with quality ingredients. That extra-crispy crust really made this pizza stand out. It had that perfect crunch on the bottom and edges while still having a great texture inside. The toppings had plenty of flavor, and everything worked together exactly the way a good pizza should. We’ve had plenty of pizza over the years, and when a place gets the crust, toppings, cheese, and overall flavor right, it’s worth giving them credit. Johnny’s Pizza definitely got it right with this one. It was one of those pizzas where you finish a slice and immediately want another one. Five stars all the way! If you like a good hamburger and pepperoni pizza, especially with a crispy crust, give Johnny’s Pizza a try. We’ll definitely be ordering from them again!
• GA

  Gregory Alexander

  Aug 26, 2026
  5.0
  Small, good, traditional and friendly.
• BB

  Brenda Lee Burgos

  Aug 14, 2026
  5.0
  I absolutely love love love this location!!!! James and Amanda are the absolute BEST!!! The establishment is very clean and organized. Service is impeccable and the food is nothing short of AMAZING!!! This is definitely NY Pizza and the cherry on top & the warm welcome 100% and absolute best service takes it over the top!!! So sad I'm moving in less than 2 mos. I will definitely miss this place and crew .
• AA

  Anna Anna

  Jul 19, 2026
  3.0
  First try, and probably my last. The crust was too thick and doughy, and the bottom was covered with burnt cornmeal-like bits. I had to brush them off before eating.
• AH

  Aamer H

  Jul 18, 2026
  2.0
  FOOD SAFTY CONCERNS I was disappointed that my pizza box was not sealed when it was delivered through DoorDash. As a customer, I believe sealed packaging is an important food safety and tamper-evident measure that gives customers peace of mind. I called the restaurant and spoke with the manager, James, to suggest that all delivery orders be sealed before being handed to DoorDash drivers. He told me that if I wanted the pizza box sealed, I would have to call the restaurant and request it in advance. I respectfully disagree. I believe every delivery order should be sealed automatically, not only upon request. Customers have no way of knowing whether a pizza box has been opened after it leaves the restaurant, and a simple tamper-evident seal would help build confidence and ensure food safety. Many restaurants already seal all of their delivery orders as a standard practice, and it makes customers feel much more comfortable. I hope Johnny’s New York Pizza will consider adopting this policy for every delivery order to better protect customers and improve their overall experience.

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza