Sal’s Neighborhood Pizzeria

Reviews

• KR

  Karol Radovich

  3 days ago
  5.0
  On vacation, came back 2 days later. Bruschetto was outstanding.
• CW

  Chelsea Whittington

  Aug 12, 2026
  5.0
  I love chicken Parmesan and after a week of sea food I finally decided to treat myself on our last day on the island. I ordered to go and it was top 2 meals I’ve had since we’ve been at St. Simon’s island including the 4 that EVERYONE raves about! It compares to fiddlers and Porch. It’s quaint but the food is delicious and the portions were enough to feed two people! Highly recommend! They were even nice enough to let me order to go at 8pm🫣
• TC

  Tripp Calloway

  Aug 5, 2026
  5.0
  Amazing red sauce place! Definitely feels like a hidden gem for locals as I never see any travel blog content on this spot. Truly fantastic food. The sauce is among the best I’ve ever had. HUGE portions for my chicken parm entree. Pizza is outstanding. Well done!
• SF

  Sara Figueroa

  Jul 24, 2026
  4.0
  My family and I enjoyed stumbling upon this quaint Italian spot. The food was good- we got a couple pizzas, mozzarella sticks which the kids devoured, and the calamari was just ok.
• TP

  Tay Patterson

  Jul 19, 2026
  1.0
  Here visiting. Ordered food, was told to be ready at 6. Wasn’t ready till 6:20. Canoli sat out for 40 minutes and it was all melted. Staff was very rude told us we couldn’t sit at the bar if we weren’t 21, which we are. Made us move all around the restaurant while waiting for our food. Just disappointed with the customer service. For a family restaurant not very nice.