Pizza 54

Reviews

• CE

  Chelsea Ellis

  3 days ago
  3.0
  The boneless wings were ok, but the Tequila sunrise was amazing along with great staff and customer service. I will be trying their pizza next time.
• DG

  Don Groh

  May 17, 2026
  1.0
  I had a pizza delivered… was cold had to be reheated in microwave which made it awful.. Why can’t this place use an insulated pouch for delivery NOT A CARDBOARD BOX!!!!
• JC

  Joshua Cheatwood

  May 17, 2026
  5.0
  Most amazing place that it took me forever to find. Don't be like me! Run don't walk! Ask for Mason!
• AA

  Alessandra

  May 5, 2026
  5.0
  Pizza 54 is hands down the BEST pizza in Peachtree City - honestly, one of the top spots in all of Metro Atlanta. It’s that good. Seriously! I took my husband here tonight for his birthday, and we were blown away. From the salad to the wings to the pies, everything came out hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious. The owner, Mike, was incredibly kind, and we received excellent service from the bartender/ our server, Blake. This was our first visit, but it definitely won’t be our last; we will be regulars from here on out. They’ve earned our loyalty. Thank you for such a great evening filled with amazing food!
• JM

  J Marie

  May 1, 2026
  2.0
  I’ve ordered from here twice now and both times have been disappointed with the portion sizes for the price. First order was a large pepperoni and ricotta pizza for $23. The ricotta dollops were scattered far apart, the pepperoni count was maybe 15-18 pieces across the whole pie, and the basil, which is the cheapest ingredient, was the most generous topping on there. Second order was a chicken bacon ranch pizza. I was told it came with 6 oz of chicken. What arrived looked closer to 3-4 oz (at best) small, sparse pieces per slice. The bacon was barely a sprinkle. And the ranch? Drizzled heavily across the entire pizza, which does a great job of making a nearly bare pizza look fuller than it is. When I called to address my concerns, the owner was firm that he doesn’t under-portion. Fair enough..so I texted him photos of both pizzas at his request. He never responded. If you’re going to ask a customer for evidence and then go silent, that tells you everything about how seriously this place takes feedback. I’ve looked at other non-chain pizza places in the area and the difference is night and day. Competitors have toppings so generous you can barely see the cheese. Here, the cheese IS the topping. For $23+ a pie, you deserve better. I’d skip this place and support one of the other local spots that actually values their customers and loads up their pizzas.