Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• CC

  Christina Cox

  Jun 6, 2026
  1.0
  We frequent this Johnny's often and the food is delicious but unfortunately tonight was our last visit. We enjoyed watching a sweet moment as 3 teenage girls ran out the door to thank a family that had paid for their meal in secret. This then turned into an opportunity for prayer, as I overheard the girls were going through some things. It was a really beautiful moment that gave me some hope in humanity, until I looked to the counter where I saw multiple employees pointing and laughing at them in front of the whole restaurant, repeatedly. While I understand not everyone has the same beliefs, a level of respect is still expected. Especially from your employees. The whole situation put a very sour taste in my mouth about this establishment. I would certainly hope someone speaks to the employees about having some basic respect and maybe just a little human decency towards others, especially your customers.
• AD

  Andrii Danylov

  Jun 5, 2026
  5.0
  I am rare coming here during lunch but this place deserves much more offen visits. We had a lot of people and been outside. Pizza 🍕 was super good. It was good buy party. They didn't rush but today it was what I needed. I wish to stuck there with colleges, drink soda and talk. It's very American place and that's what good in them. I had to admit that they made such big Pizza that it is enough for me to eat 2 days. Come here and give it a try if you still have not visited them and you will return again
• SS

  Shannon Scruggs

  Jun 4, 2026
  4.0
  I’ve been going to Johnny’s Pizza for 15+ years to enjoy their cold Miller Lite draft beer and a slice. I went in yesterday afternoon after a hot day at work to enjoy a cold one, and was surprised to find out that they replaced their Miller Lite taps with Coors Light. Coors Light! Really? Yuck. That’s the last beer I’d drink on tap. I now have to got to Taco Mac and just order pizza from the house now. Ughhhh! Update: Miller Lite draft is back! Thank you!!!
• PK

  Pamela Kelley

  May 24, 2026
  2.0
  Our first time at this location and will stick with the Johnny's in Fayetteville. The one waitress did an amazing job by herself, but the cook apparently couldn't read the ticket and made my calzone incorrectly. It was missing two toppings, but included one unwanted topping that gives me indigestion. The flavor was not great either as it was quite bland. Hubs said my food didn't even look good. The wait for food took a while so I didn't bother asking for it to be remade, just deconstructed it to pick out unwanted topping. Regret that decision for my stomach sake, but hindsight is 20/20. Again, will be only going to Fayetteville location from this point forward.
• VD

  V. Duskren

  May 20, 2026
  3.0
  It's good, simple, and cheap. I'm from NY, and the za leaves a little to be desired, but it is good. The biggest downfall is that I really love wings, and whoever they buy their wings from seems to send "malformed" wings from time to time. And instead of discarding them, and eating the cost, Johnny's instead chooses to actually serve them to their customers... For $2 a wing, that's insanely disrespectful. I would never have put this wing on the pass. And this is a very regular occurrence. I used to get wings here a lot, but 1 of the 10 is usually malformed. It's off-putting, and unappetizing. It makes you really feel that they care more about the bottom line than you.

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza