Whits Newnan

Reviews

• JD

  John Davis

  May 11, 2026
  1.0
  So I kindly asked them not to put a lot of pecans in the Georgia Gem Whitser, and they loaded it with pecans anyway, even after emphasizing to take it easy. Great ice cream otherwise, but sucks when you ask for something you paid for to be made a certain way. And it’s get made completely the opposite from what you asked for. It was so much in there, it almost felt intentional. So won’t be going back to this location. Very unfortunate! Not sure how a lil Pecans end up being about 60 plus in the cup
• PW

  Patricia Warner

  May 3, 2026
  1.0
  Don’t go on Sundays if you want good service. We placed our order and the lady wrote it incorrectly in her system and the man came to the window and continued to try to convince me that I ordered what she wrote versus what I’ve ordered over the last few years that I’ve ordered from them.( I only get 3 choices there- my 3 FAVORITES ) We normally go on Fridays or Saturdays, I think we will stick to those days the younger teens get the orders right and are so friendly! He shut the door in our faces, so unprofessional.
• C8

  Clarissa 8

  Apr 12, 2026
  5.0
  Make an order through text and when we finally get our orders. I make a mistake for ordering the wrong size. I was so embarrassed but Juliet (Cashier) told that it's okay. Juliet is very accommodating and respectful. I did asked if they can make my order to a quart size. Juliet asked one of her co-worker, Jackie who didn't hesitate to go above and beyond her responsibilities. Jackie gladly did our orders. We have been buying Whits Custard for years and all the employees that we interact are always have great customer service. But I would like to send a big Thank you to Jackie for an excellent service with a great smile 😃 😊
• FW

  Fred Waller

  Apr 11, 2026
  5.0
  Kids love it here. Will be back!
• KC

  Kathy Clark

  Apr 4, 2026
  1.0
  IT seems as if Nick does not know how to plan for the flavor of the day. I have been there numerous times now and they have been "out" of the flavor of the day.

Frequently Asked Questions About Whits Newnan