Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• MS

  Mara Scott

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Haven’t been here in at least two years. They had a new spicy bbq peach flatbread - delicious! But the main reason I’d go back now? Our waitress, Selina, was amazing! So friendly and kind and attentive. Great service!
• JW

  Janet Wallman

  Jul 3, 2026
  5.0
  Johnnys. I first met you when my hubby and I moved in nearby, 3 years ago, and we were starving and hot from moving all day. You impressed me then. Today, I gotta say, your staff impressed me even more. I have weird food allergies. I’m allergic to basil. And not only did your staff take that into account, my waitress double checked with the kitchen, and listed off all ingredients for the Johnnys White, and even stepped up and removed the basil mixed ricotta from the pie, I didn’t even know there was basil in the ricotta, but she worked miracles. And then. I decided the white pizza was too delish to share with my husband(sorry boo), so I went ahead and ordered a Meatza for him. You chef came over and asked if he needed to sub the marinara with the white pizza base! I was blown away. Absolutely blown away. I told him, nah you’re good. The hubby doesn’t have allergies and this one is for him. Still. The care. The consideration. The attentiveness. Johnnys. You guys knocked the baseball not only out of the park, but to the next galaxy today. Thank you so much!
• MJ

  Mr J

  Jul 2, 2026
  3.0
  The pizza taste better than frozen but not as good as fresh the big chains pizza. The garlic sticks are definitely not worth it
• CC

  Chris Cameron

  Jun 20, 2026
  1.0
  I have been a loyal customer of Johnny’s Pizza for the past two years, ordering two pizzas every Tuesday night. Unfortunately, after the way this situation was handled, I will not be returning. I placed and paid for an order online. When my husband picked up the pizzas, he was charged again at the store for the same order. I understand that mistakes happen, but what matters is how a business responds when a mistake is brought to their attention. The next day, I went in person to address the issue and was told the manager was not there. I then called for the next two days and was told I would receive a call back, which never happened. After receiving no response, I returned in person with my bank statements showing the duplicate charges. Instead of taking responsibility or even attempting to resolve the issue, I was told it did not happen and was refused a refund. That is unacceptable. A loyal customer should not have to chase a business for days, provide proof, and still be dismissed. This was not about the amount of money. This was about integrity, accountability, and basic customer service. The previous ownership would have made this right without hesitation. Sadly, that is clearly not the standard anymore. Word of mouth is one of the most powerful forms of advertisement, and I will make sure people know about my experience. I strongly caution anyone considering ordering from this location. Check your receipts, check your bank statements, and do not assume that a mistake will be corrected. Based on my experience, loyalty and proof meant nothing.
• GJ

  G Jones

  May 31, 2026
  1.0
  I really do try not to leave negative reviews because everybody can have a bad day. People can get sick and call out. You name it, it can happen. And this particular restaurant has come a long way from where they were just a few years ago. But tonight I called at 6:48 p.m. and the lady told me immediately that it would be at least an hour wait. They close at 8:00. So I asked her if that was the case for meatballs, because that's what I intended to order. Just meatballs. She said yes. I decided not to wait and we'll figure something else out for supper. You can see by the graph that Google updates in real time that the place was not that busy, even for a Sunday night. I'm not sure exactly what happened tonight to cause this problem, but I will say I expect better. If you want to see how a Johnny's Pizza is supposed to run, check the one out in Stockbridge on Eagles Landing Parkway. Even the ones in Macon and Warner Robins have gotten a lot better. I'm leaving this review in hopes that management or the owner will get in touch with me.

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza