Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• HM

  Hannah “H M” Mabe

  Jun 21, 2026
  5.0
  Very friendly staff. Super fast service. We had flatbreads & pizzas both delish and served hot.
• AL

  Ayla Lisenby

  Jun 18, 2026
  4.0
  We've been here multiple times and the only reason I'm giving the service 3 stars is because it's 50/50 on whether or not we good a good waiter/waitress. Mind you, we are a party of 7, 3 adults and 4 children. I get it we're a big party with a lot of children and no one likes to wait on children. The last time we there we got a waitress who you could tell was a mother with how attentive she was to our table and children. Tonight however was a different story. After receiving our meal our waitress just completely disappeared, we asked for another, didn't get it, we need refills for the kids drinks, had to go up there after looking for her for 20 minutes. When we went in it wasn't busy, but around the time or meal came it did start picking up. The manager I believe was very friendly and he did come and check up on us. I understand if she needed to take a break or got busy but please send someone to tell us, because disappearing for over 20 minutes is crazy. We were done with our food before I had to go up there for refills and the check. I hate leaving bad reviews. The food is really good, great selection for a pizza joint. Caesar salad was great aside from a couple of brown pieces, the bruschetta is amazing and we got two kinds of pizzas, the steak and cheese and the veggie. Both were delicious.
• DL

  Diane Lockhart

  Jun 9, 2026
  5.0
  Best Pizza spot in Macon, beats all the fast food Pizza chains.
• JB

  Jesse Bunde

  Jun 7, 2026
  5.0
  The pizza was absolutely amazing, Iv had plenty of NYC style pizza and this place is by far the best and closest representation of what pizza is like in the city. My family being from nyc I grew up being very particular about pizza, and you guys nailed it, if only you could have nyc water shipped down here to make the dough, then you couldn’t be able to tell the difference. The thickness of the crust, the ratio of cheese to sauce, the way it’s cooked is spot on. Just everything about it is dang near identical.
• MM

  Matt

  May 27, 2026
  5.0
  First time at this location and it was great. I’m from New York, so I was excited to see if this was really New York-style pizza — and it absolutely was. The staff was super friendly, especially Bella, and the pizza was awesome. I was definitely not disappointed. I’m not from the area, but every time I come back, I’ll definitely be stopping here for pizza again.

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza