Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• MD

  Michele Don

  5 days ago
  5.0
  WE visit for dinner 1/2 times a week. Excellent staff and food
• DP

  Debra Parmer

  Jun 29, 2026
  4.0
  Haven't had this pizza in years. Ordered a large cheese and mushroom today. Picked it up it was hot and cheesy, yumm, but, the sauce is off-putting. I can't seem to put my finger on it but it ruined the entire expierience for me, I really wanted to love this pizza.
• JG

  Jack Armstrong Local Guide

  Jun 12, 2026
  5.0
  Johnny’s Pizza always delivers when you’re looking for comfort food and a cold beer. The New York-style pepperoni flatbread had a thin crust, plenty of cheese, and that classic foldable slice appeal. The Stromboli was loaded with steak, peppers and Chesse fillings came out piping hot with a flavorful marinara on the side. Needed just a touch more browning on top. The baked ziti was rich, cheesy, and easily large enough to share. Even the side salad was fresh and generously topped with ham, cheese, and vegetables instead of feeling like an afterthought. We paired it all with ice-cold lager and hazy draft beers served in frosted mugs, which hit the spot on a warm Georgia evening. Service was friendly, food came out quickly, and the covered patio is a great option when the weather cooperates. Johnny’s may not be fancy, but it consistently delivers good portions, reasonable prices, and exactly what you expect from a neighborhood pizza place. Recommended: Pepperoni pizza, calzone, baked ziti, and an ice-cold draft beer.
• AR

  Abby R

  May 4, 2026
  2.0
  They are getting 2 stars bc when I was here a couple of weeks ago we got 2 calzones and the garlic knots and 1 of the calzones and the garlic knots were under-cooked. As in, raw dough. I emailed the company and never heard back, so they're getting a crappy review.
• CM

  Cole Mixson

  Apr 26, 2026
  5.0
  Are you ever looking for a great restaurant to go have an amazing experience? I have your place, Johnnys Pizza. If your favorite restaurant needs to have great pizza, great service, great sweet tea, and an overall phenomenal experience, Johnny’s is the place for you. My wife and I genuinely go there at LEAST once a week, if it’s a Friday or Saturday we are there. If we ever have some spare time after work, we are there. Football and baseball season it’s the place to be. There’s nothing like watching a braves game or bulldogs game while eating a great pizza with your wife. We always leave with a smile on our face hungry for more. The best part about Johnny's pizza is counting down the days till your next visit. The friendly atmosphere and kind service makes it one of the best restaurants in Walton county, dare I say all of Georgia. If my friends ever need a recommendation or just want to go hang out and grab a bite, I send them straight to Johnnys. We ate there last night and there’s a chance we will be back later for dinner again today. Thank you Johnny’s for being the best pizza place in all of the world.

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza