Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• SL

  Silver Butterflies LLC

  May 12, 2026
  5.0
  Good customer services. We love their fries they have a good seasoning on them and they taste really good.
• AP

  Amanda Patsy

  May 6, 2026
  2.0
  This used to be my go to place for lunch. But not anymore! Especially when ordering take out. The food quality has declined as well as the service and wait times. Very disappointed.
• RP

  Rip Puckett

  Apr 22, 2026
  5.0
  I always have great food, great service and great times when im at johnnies on sugarloaf
• MD

  Morgan Decker

  Apr 15, 2026
  2.0
  I had a really disappointing experience at this Johnny’s location. I used to work at a Johnny’s in Athens for two years, exclusively in the kitchen, so I’m very familiar with the difference between the wing sauces. Mild, medium, and hot are not the same sauce. Mild is its own brighter orange buffalo sauce, while hot is a darker red and has a slightly smoky smell. Medium is made by cutting the hot sauce with margarine. I ordered a buffalo chicken pizza with mild sauce because my wife is sensitive to spicy foods. When I picked it up, I immediately noticed the sauce looked dark red instead of the brighter orange mild sauce I expected, and it also had that slight smoky smell. I asked the person at the counter to check with the kitchen, and after checking, she told me it was mild, so I took them at their word and brought it home. Once we tried it, it was obvious it was not mild. I have a decent spice tolerance and could tell right away, and it was far too hot for my wife. Luckily, we had ordered half the pizza as cheese and bacon, otherwise the whole order would have been a waste. I called the store to let them know the pizza had the wrong sauce. To be fair, the person who answered the phone did apologize, and I appreciate that. But the store still insisted that the pizza was made with mild sauce and gave an explanation about the sauce “settling” if it is not shaken enough, which did not line up with my experience working in the kitchen at Johnny’s. I had to specifically ask for some kind of compensation, and only then did they say they could do $2 off next time. What bothered me most was not just the wrong sauce, but how it was handled. Mistakes happen. But when a customer raises a legitimate issue, the right response is to take it seriously and make it right, not repeatedly insist the order was correct and then only offer $2 off after being pressed. We’ve gone to this location often, which made this especially frustrating. Because of how this was handled, we won’t be back.
• KP

  Karen P.

  Apr 4, 2026
  5.0
  Johnny's has been a family favorite for nearly 26 yrs and their pizza is just as good nw as it was then! They also have outstanding calzones. They are HUGE! Family friendly atmosphere. I gave 4 stars for atmosphere and service bc no one is perfect and perfect service is hard to do. Go eat at Johnny's! You won't be disappointed!

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza