Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• PM

  Patty Moreno

  2 days ago
  4.0
  When we arrived, our server was very busy so we definitely took note of that. All of the food was excellent except for the sandwich. One slice of each meat and one slice of cheese and way too much bread. Super disappointing. The pizza and the calzones were amazing. The Server did awesome Except after she brought her food, we never saw her again. Literally never saw her again. Had to find someone else to get us boxes and to close out our check.
• BM

  Brian Martin

  May 12, 2026
  5.0
  Great service, great food!!! Have been multiple times!!! Flatbreads are great! Obviously the pizza is on point as well!!!!
• DD

  Deb

  May 7, 2026
  1.0
  Horrible experience. Don't go on bingo night unless you wear ear phones. Guy screaming B3. B3. B3 as if we didn't hear it the first two times. $7 salad came with a container of Ken's dressing. Pizza was like cardboard. No sauce. Eggplant just added little pieces of cardboard. I won't be going back. The folks serving behind the bar were great.
• MB

  Michelle Block

  May 3, 2026
  5.0
  It wasOur first time there, we had a reservation.But the table had been taken and the people were not leaving, so they opened up another room to accommodate.That is five star in my book right there. The service was fantastic and the food was fabulous.We will be back again a great place to go.
• AD

  Andrew Dempsey

  Apr 24, 2026
  3.0
  I ordered online this evening and the wait was 50 minutes. Once I arrived I heard others had been waiting for an hour. It’s a Friday night and not a ton of dining options in the area so the wait was to be expected and staff was very polite and attentive. I did get home finally and found that the garlic knots were wayy over cooked and some were burned. I understand a little over cooked but this is not something that should’ve been packaged up and sent out the door. Not impressed with this order tonight but overall the staff is great and the environment is wonderful. Pizza was worth the wait.