Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• DD

  Dennis Buck (dbucknh)

  Aug 24, 2026
  5.0
  Always a favorite! We are there every Thursday evening for dinner and DJ Bingo. We all love the hand tossed NY style pizza, hot from the oven.
• AG

  Ayleen Danica Gärtner

  Aug 19, 2026
  2.0
  Pizza was "okay". In my opinion not more than that though. Tasted pretty bland, had way too much cheese and putting canned pineapple under "specialty topping" and charging a higher price for it is not really reasonable. Atmosphere was okay, service was good. The toilet did not work and had a plunger next to it already!! Maybe some others like what I didn't but that's okay. Was just not for me.
• JE

  Jim Earp

  Aug 17, 2026
  4.0
  We were on a long trip, and heading south toward Macon. I noticed this location and we stopped in. Very nice casual pizza place, great menu. I had a small Mediterranean salad-not small, by the way, and my wife had a two slice lunch special. Both were great, a value at $21 for both with two drinks.
• MB

  Makai Bradfield

  Aug 10, 2026
  2.0
  My friends and I came here for lunch. They sat us all the way in the corner of the restaurant aways from everyone else right underneath the A/C. I watched the servers approach other tables while we waited about 45 mins for anyone to even ask us what we wanted to drink. When we did get services, the waiter only came to our table one time to check on us. This place is ran by children and I won’t be coming back. They absolutely create an uncomfortable environment for people of color, don’t waste your money here.
• TS

  Timyda Shanks

  Aug 8, 2026
  1.0
  My fiancé and I visited this restaurant last night, and unfortunately, our experience was not only disappointing—it was extremely disrespectful and, in my experience, racially motivated. When we arrived, we were told our food would take approximately 20–30 minutes. We sat at the bar and ordered drinks while we waited. After about 50 minutes, I asked about our food. The young lady went to check and came back saying it would be another 10–15 minutes. I asked again later for an update, and eventually our food came out. The pizza was cold, the bottom of the calzone/stromboli was burnt, and our salad was missing. At that point, I asked to speak with the manager. Instead of trying to resolve the situation, the manager came out with what I felt was an extremely rude and dismissive attitude and basically told us that everyone had been waiting over an hour, so there was nothing she could do. Things escalated because of the way we were treated. I left the restaurant, and my fiancé remained behind because he was still trying to pay for what we had ordered. He was repeatedly told to leave. He explained that he was trying to pay, but they continued telling him to leave and said they would take care of it. We eventually left. The restaurant later contacted the police. The police spoke with us about what happened and told us that our stories matched and that there would be no criminal charges filed. We were, however, told that the restaurant did not want us to return. What makes this experience even more upsetting is that we felt we were treated differently because of our race. Nobody should have to walk into a restaurant, spend their money, wait an unreasonable amount of time for cold and burnt food, and then be treated with disrespect when they ask for the problem to be addressed. There were multiple opportunities for management to simply apologize, correct the food, and treat us with basic respect. Instead, the situation was handled in a way that left us feeling humiliated and unwelcome. I am sharing this review because customers deserve to know what happened to us. Poor service is one thing. Being made to feel discriminated against and unwelcome because of the color of your skin is something completely different. I would not recommend this restaurant based on our experience.

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza