Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• AT

  Alicia Tamayo

  May 29, 2026
  1.0
  I ordered a slice of cheese pizza for my toddler, and the experience was disappointing from start to finish. First, it took nearly an hour after ordering to receive the original slice. When it finally arrived, it was paper-thin, had almost no sauce, and barely any cheese on it. It honestly looked unfinished. I asked the server if this was normal, and she told me it depended on who was cooking that day. She did offer to have it remade, which I appreciated. Unfortunately, when the replacement came out about 10 minutes later, it was clearly the exact same pizza with a little extra cheese melted on top. The crust, shape, and lack of sauce were identical. It did not appear to be a fresh remake. Needless to say, my toddler didn’t eat any of it. Luckily she took to my calzone so she could finally eat. The server was kind and tried to help, but between the extremely long wait and the poor quality of the pizza, especially for something as simple as a cheese slice for a child, the experience was very frustrating. Based on this visit, I wouldn’t order pizza here again. Original on left, “replacement” on right.
• SW

  Sheila Wood

  May 11, 2026
  5.0
  We ordered a pizza and spaghetti with meatballs for 3 of us! It was really good! We had no leftovers! The only downside was the child-sized spaghetti was a really small portion.
• KG

  Kairy Garcia

  Apr 20, 2026
  5.0
  Very good food, my family and I enjoyed everything!! the pizza was delicious! great service too:) !!
• SS

  Sue Ellen Scott

  Apr 6, 2026
  1.0
  Got a Cesar salad and spent 8$ on the smallest salad that didn’t even have croutons in it when it’s supposed to come with them. Me and my boyfriend had a To-go order so we didn’t check but so disappointed and felt robbed of my money, the one thing I want on my salad is croutons and that’s why I got a Cesar and it didn’t even come with what it’s supposed too, absolutely disappointed and very upset…
• XW

  Xander Wood

  Feb 23, 2026
  5.0
  The pasta here is absolutely Devine and way better choice compared to hickory flat kitchen! Would always recommend this spot even to my grandchildren!