Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• JB

  Jennifer Black

  2 days ago
  1.0
  My family and I decided to give Johnny’s a try last night, we have been before but not in a while. We arrived around 7:15 and there was only a few tables with customers but most of the empty tables were dirty. We didn’t think much about it because we assumed the evening rush had just finished. My husband and son shared an order of the cheesy garlic knots and the dough was very hard. We placed our order by 7:30 ( at the latest). It was almost 8:15 before we received our meals. There was only a few tables seated so it wasn’t like they were super busy, the waitress walked by our table during the wait and never communicated about why it was taking so long. The only time she communicated about anything was to tell me my salad was just waiting on the grilled chicken and it would be out soon, this was at least 35 minutes after placing the order. And it still took another 10 minutes or more. When she finally brought out the food the chicken was not grilled at all, it might have been boiled and shredded, most definitely not grilled. My husband ordered a slice and salad, his slice had burnt grill flakes all over the bottom but the dough was not cooked and soggy. The waitress brought him his salad and slice at the same time instead of bringing his salad while we waited for the hot food. They did take the slice off the bill but we definitely took this Johnny’s off our list of places to eat. We were extremely disappointed.
• NN

  Nikki

  6 days ago
  2.0
  I’ve lived out here for years and most recently for the past 3 weeks when we come out for trivia 2-3 times a week it’s extremely hot and unbearable. We’ve asked for the air to be turn on or up and the manager stated it has to come from the owner. It’s so disappointing I don’t think our group will be coming back until this is resolved. Why would you not have sufficient cool air circulating during a heat wave or anytime the weather is at 90 degrees or higher. The wait staff is always nice and friendly but I’m sure this has to be unsafe for them as well. A hot kitchen and serving customers, someone could easily faint due to extreme heat exposure. I hope they will care enough to do better for their employees since they won’t do it for customers who ask.
• MR

  Mike Rosario

  Jun 30, 2026
  5.0
  We had Johnnie’s Pizza yesterday it was super good Large Cheese and some lemon pepper wings. It hit the spot and was flavorful. The pizza was done quick and the service was excellent.
• EH

  Eilsa Hen

  Jun 22, 2026
  1.0
  Never in my life has I ever seen such unprofessionalism, this “establishment” has a cook (heavy set caucasian girl, brown hair) playing with dough, putting it on a person’s head, laughing at the top of her lungs and I’m waiting 25 minutes for a SLICE of pizza. I saw another girl go up to talk to her (I guess to say not to play around) and the cook laughed in her face. If this is the type of person Johnny’s employs I’ll go to the villa rica location. Ridiculous.
• TK

  Tony Kit

  Jun 22, 2026
  1.0
  This place is disgusting. Was there yesterday and saw a cook playing with dough and putting it on another persons head. When the manager went to talk to her about it all she did was laugh. Will never be coming back here. Thats unacceptable and I will be calling the health department.

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza