Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• BH

  B Hilton

  5 days ago
  1.0
  We went there yesterday for the first time and it will be the last. The service was terrible and my husband has been throwing up all night and is still sick. The food was so bad. When we first arrived there was only four tables occupied and there was three men behind the counter. No one acknowledged us so we finally sat in a booth and no one came after a while we saw someone pick up an order at the register so we got up and stood at the register to see if we needed to order there. Nothing. So we got a paper menu and was reading it there waiting for help. Nothing. Finally, a woman came from the back, it the bathroom, and told us we had the wrong menus and told us to sit on a booth. The food was terrible. We ordered two dinners, salad was not fresh, and a sausage in my husband's dish was so hard you couldn't cut it. Mine wasn't much better. Never again.
• JD

  Joshua Dolina

  Jul 25, 2026
  5.0
  Tonight, Johnny’s Pizza did an outstanding job taking care of our B Shift Canton Light Press Team and the Maintenance Department at Universal Alloy Corporation. From the moment the order was placed to the final delivery, everything was handled professionally. Lisa, the owner, was absolutely amazing to work with and made sure every detail was taken care of. A special thank you to Cody and Kayla for flawlessly executing such a large order and delivering it right to our facility. The food was hot, fresh, and exactly what our team needed after a long shift. It’s not often a restaurant leaves this kind of impression on an entire production floor, but Johnny’s Pizza certainly did. Their name is already being passed around the plant, and I have no doubt they’ll be seeing more business from our team. If you’re looking for great pizza backed by exceptional customer service, I highly recommend Johnny’s Pizza. Thank you again! we’re already looking forward to next time!
• GG

  Grant Gober

  Jul 23, 2026
  2.0
  Really surprised by the rating. I went for lunch and it wasn’t good the lady seemed annoyed, might’ve been a bad day. I see a lot of people one or two nights a week playing games out front. Maybe it’s different then.
• ML

  Mark Lyons

  Jun 13, 2026
  5.0
  If you’re going to take our order without writing it down, you better get it right.
• JH

  Jennifer Hopkins

  May 29, 2026
  5.0
  Had lunch there with my MIL--they have some great lunch deals, and the pizza was delicious! Not to mention the great staff!