Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• SM

  SATANIC LIVES MATTER

  Sep 26, 2026
  3.0
  I placed an order at the resturant on a Thursday afternoon , I asked for a menu I asked the cashier, “Do you still sell pizza by the slice?” and she replied, “Yes”. I told her I want 3 slices of the 16’ pizza. This is how it is written on the menu; I added a few toppings and a drink. I said that was it for my order. I was wondering why my total came up to $27.00. I was waiting for a while then she told me that my ‘2 pizzas’ would be ready soon. I told her i only order 3 slices not 2 pizzas! So she then notified the cook in the kitchen to only make 3 slices and I was then refunded the difference. My order was corrected and I left. I only went to Johnny’s because it was a resturant I used to visit when I was a teenager and haven’t had it in many years and really wanted to try it again. Staff please pay close attention to us customers, after all when I visited the store it was on a Thursday, 4 pm when only 2 customers were at the bar. The resturant was not busy at all so some order accuracy would have been nice.
• MM

  Melissa Minore

  Sep 17, 2026
  5.0
  Every time we go-the food and atmosphere is great!!! MUCH better than the Spout Springs location. And an extra special thank you to this location for donating to my Kindergarten classroom so my kids can make shapes pizzas!!! You guys are the best-we will be coming to you from now on!
• KR

  Kimberly Ray-Mcmillon

  Aug 31, 2026
  5.0
  Huge restaurant and the Service was excellent, the vegetable was fresh and delicious but as a Vegan, it would of been nice if the pizza had Plant base Cheese
• WC

  WJ C

  Aug 23, 2026
  1.0
  Terrible garlic knots today. Felt like I was eating raw dough
• JD

  Jennifer Davis

  Jul 5, 2026
  1.0
  Worst pizza I’ve had in a long time. It doesn’t even taste like real pizza.