Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• JD

  Jennifer Davis

  5 days ago
  1.0
  Worst pizza I’ve had in a long time. It doesn’t even taste like real pizza.
• EP

  Elexia Parsons

  May 23, 2026
  2.0
  Ordered from here honestly on accident thinking I was ordering from a Johnny’s in Suwanee. Man.. it was terrible. My chicken parm had like a dollop of marinara on it. It was just chicken, cheese, and dry noodles. My son’s wings look and taste burnt and had no lemon pepper on them. My daughter couldn’t choke down her fettuccine Alfredo because it was dry and had the strangest flavor (I tried it, not good at all). My husband said his Stromboli was ok, hence 2 stars instead of 1. Most egregiously, because it just shows a lack of care... they gave us just 2 pieces of extremely burnt bread with our pasta. How do you let food like that go out to a customer, whether they order pickup OR dine-in? I paid $70+ with the tip on this food and I feel bad I subjected my kids to that.
• EM

  Elizabeth M.

  Apr 30, 2026
  1.0
  Ordered dinner and I personally got the chicken fettuccine Alfredo. It was the most disgusting thing I’ve ever had out to my mouth! A frozen $1.98 version from Walmart is better. Lacks flavor and the chicken is shredded to the tiniest pieces ever. Pizza was good I am told. Garlic knots are chewy and tasted like grease. Save yourself and go further down Hamilton Mill to the Italian place near Walmart or the one over by Wendy’s by Home Depot.
• BB

  Brian Hah • Hope with Brian

  Apr 17, 2026
  5.0
  Great local pizza shop that supports the local cub scouts. We had a committee meeting here for our local Buford cub scouts and Johnny's pizza allowed us to have a meeting there. All members ordered food and drink there and the experience was wonderful. They sell pizza by the slice which was nice and their garden salad with blue cheese was wonderful. Parking is easy and plentiful and the atmosphere is very welcoming and positive. 5 stars for Johnny's New York Style Pizza of Buford!
• FM

  Frank Monello

  Apr 10, 2026
  5.0
  Just moved to GA week ago and ordered a pizza 🍕 It became my favorite. Be careful of the wings they can over cook them