Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• DB

  D Benford

  Oct 7, 2026
  1.0
  I ordered a pizza with veggies and ground beef. I'm not complaining about the driver and that is another story. But the pizza was delivered with no safety tape or extra measures to protect the food. The box was just handed over to the driver as is. The box could of easily been open and tampered with. It was my first and last time ordering with Johnny's New York pizza. I didn't even eat the PIZZA. Especially after I saw the conditions of the drivers car. I just couldn't eat the pizza. $40 wasted ... I understand times are hard and people are trying to make ends meet. But the pizza place needs to do better to protect the food. Never again from Johnny's Pizza
• HA

  Hank Alden

  Oct 4, 2026
  4.0
  It was a pleasant surprise to find this nice clean restaurant uncrowded on Saturday night!?!
• LP

  leslie pace

  Sep 29, 2026
  5.0
  When I need that "big back", action I can count on Johnny's Pizza, to pack the pounds that I desperately need on a Friday or Saturday night 🌙
• JJ

  Jamie Jolley

  Sep 9, 2026
  1.0
  HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE!! If I didn’t have to leave any stars I would not! My husband and I went 2 days in a row when we knew better to go the 2nd day. Yesterday as we walked in to place a to go order there were 2 other families with messed up orders prior to us, and the female employee argued with them both about fixing it!! We still placed our order and took it to go, and it was not as ordered. As we decided to try it again and order something different WHAT A NIGHTMARE! We only ordered 2 single slices when we got them they were burnt, we asked them to re-make it they did but put raw ingredients on them. I took 2 bites and gave it back, AK an employee wanted to tell me he would not be taking it off the bill because it was made 2 times (like that was our fault) which made no sense. When I asked for a manager NO EMPLOYEE IN THERE KNEW OF A MANAGER OR OWNERS NAME. THEY ALL STOOD THERE COMPLETELY DUMB FOUNDED…AK proceeds to say it was his place. After he argued for 30 minutes about taking a $7.00 slice of pizza off that I gave back, he stood in front of my husband as he was finishing his slice, stood there right in front of him staring..my husband asked him to please move from in front of him as he was still eating, he would not. My husband asked him a 2nd time to please move and told him HE FELT LIKE HE WAS TRYING TO INTIMIDATE HIM, AK STILL WOULD NOT MOVE AWAY!! Finally a different employee with NO NAME, did come out to calm the situation and was cordial although still would not release any manager or owner name said they didn’t have one. WHO DOES NOT HAVE A MANAGER OR AN OWNER?? MAKE THAT MAKE SENSE!! This situation went on for an hour..out of nowhere “Wendel” walks over and stated he was the owner. He did apologize for the experience BUT NOT ONE TIME WAS ANY COMPENSATION GIVEN OR OFFERED AT ALL. DO NOT WASTE A PENNY AT THIS LOCATION OR YOUR TIME!!! Below is a picture of AK who stated it was his place and he didn’t have to move but continued to cause this situation to escalate for an hour instead of just giving us our bill to take care of so we could leave, HE WENT ON AND ON TRYING TO INTIMIDATE US OVER A SLICE IF PIZZA…Wasting our time and causing ridiculous chaos with others customers in the place. THIS WHOLE SITUATION WAS ON CAMERA AND NEEDS TO BE REVIEWED 9-9-2026.Yesterday we went approximately 12:30, and today was at 4:45!
• RM

  Ry M

  Sep 8, 2026
  1.0
  This is my second time at this location and my last time giving them a chance on the most simplest food ever! Called in an order 15 mins prior to arriving for 4 slices (2 of them which were only two toppings and the other two Supreme). Not only were our supreme slices wrong (only had sausage and pep on them) but there were only 3 people in the restaurant. The cook was on his phone when we walked in and the two (Indian) ladies at the front did not want to honor their mistake or value our time especially when we called it in prior. Won’t be returning to this particular location and I would advise others the same!