McCarthy's Pub

Reviews

• SS

  Steelerzgirl333

  4 days ago
  1.0
  Not happy with new ownership. Used to be AWESOME! Did not honor what was advertised this past St Paddy day. I confronted the owner (you know, the one who thinks he can sing) and he acknowledged but still did not make it right. Not cool! Food went way downhill. Talked with employees during transition and weren't happy. We have stayed away since this past St Paddy Day but would love to return. Just please sell to another local or original owners.
• DD

  Daniel

  Jun 17, 2026
  1.0
  Hours say they open at 2pm. Got there at 3:30pm and there was no one inside except for one guy at the bat so we stood there waiting for someone to acknowledge us which didn't happen. After flagging down the bartender he said they're not even supposed to be open, but the old guy at the bar wanted to come in and watch the game so he opened the doors. Was told we'd have to wait 40min for the kitchen to be ready. Was really looking forward to trying this place, but I'm not going to just randomly show up hoping that the kitchen is able to make food. Very unprofessional.
• TF

  Thom Foster

  Jun 10, 2026
  5.0
  Great shep pie. Cold Guinness.
• PL

  paula Lombardi

  Jun 7, 2026
  5.0
  New owner Michael is truly gracious and grateful to his patrons and repeated customers. This is now my go to place. It is such a comfortable environment with the bar and TVs on one side and the divided dining area and stage on the other. It’s the perfect layout. The food and different types of music performers never disappoint. Michael is so accommodating and what a voice! You can hear a pin drop when he sings. Don’t miss out😉 oh, and the prices are truly reasonable, which is one of the most important things going out these days and the portions are very generous.
• BS

  Brenda Stewart

  Jun 3, 2026
  1.0
  So I’m not sure where to be getting here. I first visited this pub three years ago when I first arrived in Florida and I was ecstatic that I could have found a true Irish pub with authentic food.. The service was incredible and so was my dining experience. Please keep in mind. I have done reviewing on several restaurants all over the United States over the last decade.. I just recently revisited this pub after I knew new ownership had taken over and there are no words to explain the disappointment in my experience. The bartender Michael has been there for years and it was so inviting to see her familiar face. However the place was entirely empty. There’s a disco ball with apparently a karaoke night. The menu has completely changed and now serves itself better as a sports pub versus an Irish pub the Chef with no insults is nothing like what was there the food was deplorable at Best if I’m giving my fair opinion and I would say to anyone do not pay attention to any reviews that you’ve seen previous to this because it is not the same establishment.. I thought about having to leave this review since yesterday and I’m at a complete loss. There is nothing on the menu that was on there. There is no one in this facility that used to be there. It was a community gathering spot for many people who enjoyed not only the cuisine but the Service that has been available to them for many years. I can say to you that with all due respect, the Chef is not what it used to be and nothing is like it used to be, and I would say to you do not go to this establishment that considers itself to be an Irish pub which is not even close. Please sell This Place back to someone who knows what an Irish pub is about and get out of town and go back to California. You do not belong here and you’ve lost all your business.