TOMATO JOE’S NEW YORK PIZZERIA

Reviews

• SS

  Sarah Spicer

  May 2, 2026
  5.0
  My daughter and I love this place! It’s our favorite neighborhood restaurant and our go-to for pizza. The garlic knots have become my secret weapon for dinner parties, people go crazy over them! The service has always been personable and warm and the food is consistent and delicious. If you haven’t already, please check them out.
• SD

  sebastian Diaz

  May 2, 2026
  1.0
  New guy is not as good as the other Spanish guy specially for the price they charge per pizza . Went two times and the pizza didn't have enough ingredients. Really disappointed now 😞 gotta find a new spot
• MH

  Makayla Hollback

  Apr 25, 2026
  5.0
  We drive all the way from Homosassa just for this pizza! Best pizza place around! Everyone is very friendly here and well worth the hour and a half drive!!
• KC

  Katherine E. Cruz

  Apr 25, 2026
  5.0
  Ordering pizza for my office every Friday has proved problematic because we can't find anything to agree on that's good. However we no longer have that problem. Hands down best pizza I've had since I can remember. Everyone agreed. I kept getting asked "where'd you order that from?" something I never get asked. We have found our new pizza place and this is it. Tomato Joe's pizza was fresh, the sauce was on point. It was crispy and just outright delicious. Finding this place just made ordering pizza a fun experience again because we don't have to worry about being disappointed. Looking forward to pizza party Friday's at work again thanks to this place.
• SS

  Sven

  Apr 22, 2026
  5.0
  Fantastic pizza! The crust is a bit thicker than most usual New York-style pizzas but is still great! The underside is crispy, the cheese is pleasantly chewy, an the ingredients taste fresh. We tried one with extra cheese and mushrooms and was not disappointed.