Joe's New York Diner

Reviews

• VV

  Valsharie

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Jade is my favorite waitress at this place, She has such a great personality and good vibes but she is gone and it hasn't been the same. Jade COME BACK!!! Lol food is awesome and although the service is great too, its definitely not the same without her there because she definitely brought life to the place thats why i took away a star 😔
• SP

  Sarah Powell

  4 days ago
  4.0
  I have lived here all my life and have never been to this diner until now. And I have been sleeping on it! The minute you walk in, you feel a nostalgic kind of cozy. The portions are huge, prices are very fair, and the options are vast. The service was a little slow, but when you’re in a place like that, no need to rush. we really enjoyed ourselves and the food was delicious. I can’t wait to come back to try other menu items. And I absolutely love that this place is 24 hours.
• SN

  Something From Nothing

  May 10, 2026
  1.0
  Horrible service. It took over 20 minutes before our waiter even acknowledged us. The food did arrive quickly once our order was taken but the food was horrible. My burger was ordered medium rare but was overcooked and it had absolutely zero flavor. Very disappointing experience.
• DS

  Dude Smits

  May 9, 2026
  3.0
  Honestly my wife and I would probably go to this place as it's nearby maybe once a week but the cost of the food is too high. I'd guess everything cost about $2 more than it should be. I was down south today and went to Metro Diner and it was priced right. With that said the two times I've gone there, I liked the vibe, the staff was friendly and the diverse menu. Just needs to be a little cheaper for me to attend again.
• CA

  C Anon

  Apr 25, 2026
  1.0
  Poor service, worst food I ever ordered from a restaurant, way over priced! This place has been there so many years, we figured it had to be good. So we tried it out. Waiter had no idea what the veg of the day or the soup of the day was, even though from the reviews it seems the veg is always unseasoned frozen mixed veg floating in the water they were boiled in and completely tasteless. I ordered meatloaf with mashed potatoes, gravy and daily veg. Mashed seemed to be made in house, as it had lumps, but nothing at all added for flavor - no salt, no butter, no cream - just potato, very bland. Meatloaf tasted like dry dog food looks, covered in canned beef gravy. Generous portion, but who wants to eat it? Half was all I could stomach. Hubs had a chicken quesadilla. It had a couple tablespoons of grated cheese on the plate and no cheese inside. The queso in quesadilla means cheese! None. There were grilled onions inside which, along with the bland chicken, were greasy. The key word here is bland to yuck. We both had unsweetened iced teas. It was a little early for dinner - about 5:30. There wasn’t another person in the place. Nothing at all felt welcoming. The bill came to more than $50! Just stay away! They don’t deserve to be in business.