BZ
Bujar Zabelaj`
4 days ago
I live down in Jupiter, FL, and Salerno Pizza in Stuart, FL is now officially my go-to spot for authentic New York style pizza on the Treasure Coast. I walked in right before closing time, fully expecting to get rushed out the door, and instead the owner, Dave, welcomed me like a regular. Not only did he make sure I got a fresh, hot pizza, he threw in some extra goodies on the house just because. That says everything you need to know about this place. Dave is a genuinely kind man and a great business owner, the kind of person who still runs his pizzeria the old-school way, with real care for every customer who walks through the door.
Now let's talk about the pizza, because it's the real deal. If you grew up on New York pizza or you've been searching for the best pizza in Stuart, FL, stop searching. The crust is hand-tossed with that classic thin, foldable New York slice and a perfect crisp on the bottom, the sauce tastes like a family recipe, and the cheese is exactly right. You can tell everything is made fresh in-house every day, nothing frozen and nothing cut-corner. This is a true family-owned Italian pizzeria, and it shows in every bite.
The menu goes way beyond a cheese pie too. They've got Sicilian pizza, grandma pizza, white pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, and even gluten-free pizza and cauliflower crust options for anyone with dietary needs. On top of that, there are wings, garlic knots, calzones, stromboli, chicken parm subs, cheesesteaks, penne alla vodka, lasagna, and homemade desserts like cannoli and tiramisu. Whatever you're craving for lunch or dinner, this Italian restaurant has you covered.
They also offer takeout, pizza delivery, and catering, which makes it an easy choice whether you want a quick slice, a family pizza night at home, or food for an office lunch, birthday party, or game day get-together. With the football specials and family deals they run, it's great value too.
If you live anywhere in Martin County or the surrounding areas, it's absolutely worth the trip. Whether you're coming from Stuart, Port Salerno, Jensen Beach, Palm City, Hobe Sound, Sewall's Point, Port Sewall, Rio, Coral Gardens, North River Shores, Ocean Breeze, Jupiter Island, or driving up from Jupiter and Tequesta like I did, Salerno Pizza on SE Federal Highway is easy to get to and right off US-1. Locals in Snug Harbor, Seminole Shores, and Gomez are lucky to have this place so close to home.
I've eaten at plenty of pizza places across Palm Beach County and the Treasure Coast, and it's rare to find one that nails both the food and the hospitality. Most places would've been annoyed by a customer showing up at closing. Dave treated me like family and sent me home with more than I paid for. That kind of service builds loyal customers for life, and I'm definitely one of them now.
If you're searching for pizza near me, the best New York style pizza in Stuart, a reliable pizza delivery spot, or catering for your next event, Salerno Pizza is the answer. Support this local, family-owned business. You won't be disappointed. Thank you, Dave, for the hospitality and the extra goodies. I'll be back very soon, and I'm bringing friends!