O'Leary's Tiki Bar & Grill

Reviews

• ER

  Ernesto Rodriguez

  4 days ago
  4.0
  Food was not that good, we asked for grouper nuggets but we're very small, more that other restaurants, no that good tasting either, my fish sandwich was better, the blackened Mahi tasted good but the bread was awful and price wasn't that appropriate for the meal we had. No just best option in town.
• KH

  Kevin Hartman

  Jul 2, 2026
  5.0
  What else can be said about this place? Pretty much destroyed by the 2024 hurricanes and came back better than ever. Huge Tiki, outdoor bar, picnic tables in the sand, incredible water and city skyline views. Add in some live music, elevated bar food, and great cocktails, and you have the perfect recipe for a great afternoon or evening.
• MH

  Melissa Hatcher

  Jun 25, 2026
  5.0
  We love to stop at O'Learys because its on the water! The food is good and they have options for the kids. You order your food and sit wherever youd like. They have live music too!
• MC

  Michelle Cummings

  Jun 25, 2026
  5.0
  Live music, great food, sunset skies and easy vibe! This was exactly what we were looking for on a quick stop in for a casual, comfy dinner that didn't compromise on quality. We arrived just before 8 and were thrilled to find everyone still happy to help even though they close at 9:00. We ordered the Mint Condition, Siesta Beach Light, virgin pina colada, peel and eat shrimp, grilled mahi house salad, mahi tacos, and kid's chicken strips and fries. The fish was delicious! For a picnic table waterside meal, it was perfect!
• JB

  Jessica Biesok

  Jun 21, 2026
  4.0
  Love the outdoors, being right on the sand and live music. You order your food and drink then find a seat and enjoy. You pick up your food when your buzzer goes off. My husband and I visited on Saturday night (6/20). The bartender/cashier we ordered from was so friendly. I felt bad for her because two parties in front of me they couldn’t make up their mind caused a crazy backup. I ordered their “Pilar colada” and my husband the mai tai. He had the blt and I had the grilled mahi tacos. The food was good. The fries especially were delicious. Crunchy on the outside with the perfect flavoring and soft on the inside. I got two small tacos with maybe a 1ounce (probably less) mahi in each soft tortilla. Not much flavor but passable. I would have to agree with the individual that made a comment about the price here. Prior to arriving the prices seemed reasonable, however after getting our food the price is kind of high for the amount of food you receive. Honestly for each sandwich/entree we got I would say $9 - 10 is fair. For $15 give me a third taco. Make his sandwich bigger/stacked. The vibes though were amazing. Staff was friendly. I would visit again to grab some drinks and relax. Maybe an order of fries or two.

Frequently Asked Questions About O'Leary's Tiki Bar & Grill