O'Leary's Tiki Bar & Grill

Reviews

• AS

  andrea serrano

  6 days ago
  1.0
  Food is super MID. I’ve never seen a peel n shrimp served cold. This surprised me. Bar drinks are very good. But didn’t like the idea of dogs allowed. I had a lady beside me in the bar that literally put her dog on the bar table which for me was a big red flag. This is where we eat… I don’t care if this is a service dog or not. That is nasty. The bartender went ahead and told her right away which I thought was great. In general service is GREAT!!! Pete and earl were really fantastic. I could tell they work really hard to keep the place up and running and people happy. I would Come back for drinks not food.
• BB

  Batkiller

  Aug 25, 2026
  1.0
  I go there somewhat often and when I do go there I usually buy something called mermaid lemonade which is so delicious, so they have this special promotion where to only get this type of drink is buy the cup for it which cost 22 bucks. I already bought the cup since I thought it looks cool, but the thing they never tell you is to get that drink YOU HAVE TO BUY THAT CUP EVERY SINGLE TIME. Crazy right, I think what make it crazier is the people who work there knows about the drinks and will pretend they don’t know about it at all which I don’t understand why since the drink is delicious legit i came back from restaurant since I having a horrible day and want to cool down and the person who work there legit refuse to get me that drink at all.
• GW

  Gregory Wade

  Aug 25, 2026
  5.0
  ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ O’Leary’s Tiki Bar has become one of our favorite Tuesday evening traditions, and a huge part of the reason is the incredible team behind the bar. Our yoga group regularly heads over after yoga to relax, enjoy the beautiful surroundings and have a drink together, and TJ, Earl and Jose could not make us feel more welcome. They know our group, they’re genuinely personable, they’re always attentive, and they have created such a great connection with all of us. It feels like they’re genuinely happy to see us when we arrive. And these guys really know their craft. Whether it’s a cocktail or something simple, the drinks are consistently excellent. They bring together great bartending skills with terrific personalities and outstanding service. The setting at O’Leary’s is obviously special, but it’s people who turn a great location into a place you want to return to week after week. TJ, Earl and Jose are a big reason we keep coming back every Tuesday (and frankly, everyday haha). Five stars for O’Leary’s, and an extra shout-out to the Tuesday night tiki bar crew. You guys are fantastic!
• JJ

  Jacki

  Aug 25, 2026
  5.0
  I came over to visit this spot with family and friends, we happened to see hanging around the peer. The atmosphere was instantly welcoming by the bartender. I think her name is Kim, she knows the great spots to visit if you’re out of town like me. My group had some amazing food like mahi mahi tacos, mouthwatering mozzarella sticks and really good sandwiches. Omg, and the drinks were on point!! I couldn’t decide what to get so I asked for a Kim pick drink. Whatever she had concocted was just what I needed in that 100 degree heat, it was refreshing and tasted like candy. Kim was very attentive and friendly sharing the best spots to visit. Definitely put this place as a must stop for great food and service!!
• EM

  Elizabeth Martin

  Aug 25, 2026
  3.0
  My son and I went down to Sarasota to visit friends and families.We normally go to O’Leary when we come down to visit; since, they have the best Alligators bites. After waiting in a long line it was refreshing to be greeted by an extremely friendly and patient cashier named Kimmy who informed us that they no longer serve the bites. My son and I had a hard time deciding which items to get. Knowing people were waiting on us we decided to leave until Kimmy suggested several items which we decided to go with every one. The blacken mahi mahi taco, buffalo fried Colliflower, jalapeño poppers, and coconut shrimp. Both my son and I were extremely pleased. We were able to find a seat near the water, which we enjoyed as we ate.

Frequently Asked Questions About O'Leary's Tiki Bar & Grill