Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• MJ

  Madeline Jones

  Aug 23, 2026
  5.0
  Came for lunch and it was amazing. Hand made everything! Will be back for more!
• RM

  Roxanne McQueen

  Aug 22, 2026
  5.0
  We’ve been at least a half dozen times. The service has always been great. They’re friendly and fun to talk to. I like that it’s laid back, my husband loves JB’s for the service , atmosphere, and the calzones. I always order the caprese salad, and a slice /or two pizza special. One day we went when it was right after lunch hours or maybe even a weekend , but a server -an extremely nice young man , gave me the special anyway. I wish I knew his name. Today , I had the buffalo chicken flatbread, and the caprese salad. The salad was so fresh, and the flatbread was the best I’ve ever had, ever. My son and I are foodies- he lives in another state so I sent him a picture of the flatbread pizza and his response “ holy sh t” 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 My sister in law had the bruschetta app and a sandwich ( I can’t remember which one I was fixated on MY food😊) , my niece had the ceaser wrap and fries, my husband had a calzone. We didn’t have any problems and our server was great. The food delicious. I do have to mention pizza that I had previously to today’s visit. I’m not from New York so maybe it’s the way it is , 🤷‍♀️😊—BUT the pizza didn’t taste that great as it didn’t have any sauce , or barely any. The crust tasted like a frozen pizza. A couple of other “ national chains” in town serve what they call NY pizza, and we can “ fold over “ each slice. Lol There are so many other great entrees there that I can order something other than pizza. I wish the pizza was better , but honestly , “ P J’s and D…no’s” are better. It seems like the neg reviews say the same about the two chains. Pro’s : service , atmosphere , the food( other than the pizza) fun staff , reasonable prices for the food we got. Cons: the pizza isn’t my favorite 😢 Pizza a tad bit more expensive than other pizzas I’ve had for cheaper in the area ( I’m not talking national chains this time ), there are several Mom and pop pizza places around as well. Pizza 1/10 (sorry 😢) Caprese salad 10/10 Buff chicken flatbread 10/10 Calzone 10/10( that’s coming from a picky eater ❤️) Service 10/10 Atmosphere 10/10
• EK

  Eric King

  Aug 21, 2026
  4.0
  Recently had a large pizza with pepperoni and basil delivered via DoorDash to the office. Since this was our first time trying it out wanted to try something basic (If a pizza place can't do a basic pepperoni, then forget about it). Pizza arrived and we all dug in, large sliced and a generous amount of pepperoni and cheese with just enough basil on it to make it pop. Love the crust! It had the perfect amount of pull and chew that I look for with NY Style pizza. It had an excessive amount of cheese on it, not complaining, would have liked to have held back a little on the cheese. Now the sauce, the sauce lacked a little bit of flavor. You could tell it was there, but the cheese and toppings overpowered the flavor of the sauce, making it seem bland. It lacked either a lil bit of heat, some bite, or needed a hint of vinegar make ya notice it. Overall - will definitely order again. It's worth it, though the DoorDash fees inflated the cost...which isn't Brusco's fault. Definitely will have to try a dine-in experience soon! -Eric @ Leitz Music Pensacola
• MC

  Matt compton

  Aug 19, 2026
  5.0
  It's a whole dine in little restaurant with a bar. Atmosphere was nice. I had no idea this place was he. You can see the guys in the back tossing doe, idk lol, I'm geeking out. I'm definitely going next time to hit the bar and eat.
• IA

  Isaac Anderson

  Aug 19, 2026
  5.0
  Great food, service, and has plenty of seating.