Slices New York

Reviews

• JD

  Jaydavis2232 Davis

  today
  1.0
  I never write reviews, but I felt I had to because the ratings for this place are much higher than the food I received. I ordered a large Supreme because they don't offer a medium. I was really in the mood for one, but it turned out to be a huge disappointment. There were barely any toppings—honestly, not even enough for what I'd expect on a small Supreme, let alone a large. The dough was paper thin and even had holes in parts of the pizza. The center wasn't cooked through at all. What little crust there was in the middle was raw and stretchy. Every time I picked up a slice, the center of the pizza stayed behind in the box. It was basically just cheese and sauce, and even those weren't very good. For almost $30 after tax, this was a complete waste of money. Lesson learned—I won't be ordering from here again.
• TK

  Tim Kelley

  Jun 14, 2026
  1.0
  Waited 30 mins in lobby before anyone came out from kitchen area, didn’t greet any one of the 6 other people standing inside. Cheese Pizza was terrible and soggy. Ordered and asked for wings to be extra crispy, sauce just dumped on top, not tossed, with hardly enough sauce to cover tops of the wings, Wings were also soggy, rubbery and mushy on the bottom, definitely were not cooked long enough, and were not crispy whatsoever. I’ve had better experience at the worst of dominoes. Wouldn’t recommend, wouldn’t go again.
• PP

  Picklebeanz

  Jun 14, 2026
  5.0
  We ordered pizza for take out at 11pm on a Saturday night and it was delicious! Definitely a great representation of New York style! My hubby is hard to impress but he absolutely loved it as well as our kids. The garlic sticks were a little too well done for me. Didn't really like them. The place is small, with just a few table tops to sit at but no big deal. Would highly recommended!
• PK

  Peter Khalil

  Jun 1, 2026
  3.0
  The margarita tasted good but the service missed my extra cheese request. Take out only, no place to sit down. Found out that it's cheaper in store than online order 😑
• DM

  Dr. A Mustang

  May 24, 2026
  1.0
  We call on phone asking for offer they told me 2 L pizza with sticks for $50. When I get to the place was looking the menu and they have the same I order for less $48. and the pizza was cold and I have to wait more because was missing the sticks.