Mystic Lobster Roll Co - Naples, Vanderbilt Shoppes

Reviews

• KK

  Kenia

  3 days ago
  5.0
  We drove all the way from Miami after seeing a video on Instagram, and it was 100% worth the trip! This place exceeded all of our expectations. The food was absolutely delicious, fresh, and full of flavor. I ordered the Hawaiian Lobster Roll with coconut, and I honestly can’t put into words how incredible it was. The combination of flavors was unique, perfectly balanced, and unlike anything we’ve had before. Every bite was amazing, and you can tell they put a lot of care into the quality of their food. If you’re thinking about trying Mystic Lobster Roll Company, don’t hesitate—you won’t be disappointed. We’ll definitely be making the drive from Miami again!
• CS

  Chanelle Statti

  Jun 21, 2026
  5.0
  Fantastic! I was pleasantly surprised by how much lobster comes with each dish. We got the Connecticut roll, King Louis VIII roll, Yukon potatoes with garlic and Old Bay seasoning, lobster bisque, and the lobster Mac n cheese. Everything was delicious!! The price was also very reasonable. I live in New England and it’s tough to get this much lobster without paying nearly double or getting served tiny little bits of lobster. Highly recommend stopping by Mystic!
• AC

  Anthony Conti

  Jun 20, 2026
  1.0
  First of all, I lived in Maine for years and trust me this is far from Maine lobster. There was no taste. It was the worst lobster ever had in my life. To claim chowder was really potato soup. You couldn’t find any clams. Service was poor as well as the waiting time to get your food. Very, very expensive for poor quality of food. I absolutely do not recommend this place wasting your time and money
• KK

  Kyle

  Jun 19, 2026
  5.0
  Mystic Lobster Roll Co. was a great stop for fresh seafood. The lobster roll was packed with generous chunks of lobster, served on a perfectly toasted roll, and had excellent flavor without being overly dressed. The ingredients tasted fresh, and the portions were worth the price. The staff was friendly, the service was quick, and the atmosphere was relaxed and welcoming. If you’re a lobster fan or just looking for quality seafood, this place is definitely worth a visit. I’ll be coming back to try more of the menu
• DR

  Dominic Rego

  Jun 18, 2026
  5.0
  While vacationing in beautiful Naples, Florida, we discovered the BEST lobster rolls we’ve ever had. Mystic Lobster Roll Co delivers pure New England quality with Floridian energy. The lobster is incredibly fresh, sweet, and overflowing — no filler, no shortcuts, just generous chunks of perfectly prepared delight! Our first choice, the warm‑butter Connecticut roll, was absolute perfection — the bun toasted just right, doesn’t come apart like others we’ve had. Impressed, we followed it with the Old‑Fashioned New England roll and loved it just as much. The real surprise was how obsessed we became with the Hawaiian roll afterward. We fell in love with this delightful gem of a place. We even took home the Lobster Bisque and Clam Chowder — both outstanding. We had to return to try more before leaving back home, starting with the King Louis XIII (glorious), then the Deep South (spicy perfection), and of course… we had to get the Hawaiian one more time. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the whole place has that laid‑back coastal vibe that makes you want to come back the next day. If you’re in Naples and craving a true, top‑tier lobster roll, this spot is an absolute must!