Mystic Lobster Roll Co - Naples, Vanderbilt Shoppes

Reviews

• CF

  C F

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Amazing lobster roll and lobster bisque soup. We ordered the mighty sized roll; there was a larger size available but can’t image being able to finish anything more than what we had. We stopped in for a snack. Very large portions and both were more than enough for two to split. Best lobster bisque and the presentation was amazing. Lobster was so fresh. We really enjoyed. Friendly service too.
• SR

  Sam Root

  6 days ago
  5.0
  True to its name, this restaurant specializes in lobster rolls. I was thoroughly impressed by the freshness, quantity, and quality of the lobster—this is hands-down the best lobster roll I’ve found in Florida, and it isn’t even close. They use fresh Maine lobster, and because every order is made fresh to order, expect a 20- to 40-minute wait for your roll. The lobster bisque was equally top-notch, packed with generous chunks of lobster that put other versions to shame. There’s plenty of parking, and the cozy interior seats about 20 guests, with a bar as well. Overall, if you’re a fan of authentic Maine lobster and live in Florida, this place is an absolute must-try.
• EE

  Emily

  Aug 13, 2026
  5.0
  Splurge on one of these incredible lobster rolls for yourself, they are DELICIOUS!! So much lobster meat, slaw is sooo good, everything is great! Causal hole in the wall environment, you are going to wait for a good 20-30 minutes if there are others there, who cares though? It’s SO GOOD. Don’t think more about it, go get a lobster roll!
• JL

  Janice Laskau

  Aug 2, 2026
  5.0
  FABULOUS! Growing up in New England, I'm always on the hunt for GOOD/GREAT Lobster. After 20 years away from Connecticut, I've finally found GREAT lobster here at Mystic Lobster Roll. THE BEST. And the bonus is the 2 wonderful guys who run it and do everything!! And they do it with efficiency, friendliness, personality and grace. The place is clean and inviting. I can't wait to go back and savor the delicious lobster bisque and delectable lobster rolls. Bravo, guys!!
• CT

  Courtney T

  Jul 25, 2026
  5.0
  The food is bomb. I found this place through a Snapchat post from the SAME DAY and knew I had to go. I got the Connecticut Roll with mayo (which was heavily suggested) and I am ready to go back for more. It’s clean and the workers are beyond respectful of ALL personality types and ages, which can be hard to find in SWFL. They even have happy hour 3-5 every day, and we overheard men at the bar RAVING about the food and beers. Family friendly, casual date friendly, hangout friendly! You can even just do a walk in pick up if you can’t stay to eat, which I don’t know why you wouldn’t. Everything is delivered fresh daily and you can tell. I don’t even usually like cole slaw but this one was so refreshing that it was the first thing gone from my plate. Amazing, I can’t wait to go back.