Magic Lobster Roll Co - Naples, Vanderbilt Shoppes

Reviews

• VE

  Veronica Echeverry

  2 days ago
  5.0
  I tried the Connecticut, Old fashion New England and the Surf & Turf, and they were all AMAZING!!! Fast service, great customer service. Suoer recommended
• CH

  Cristian Hernandez

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Amazing place! Great flavors! And amazing people! Price wise is good for the top quality of food you get!! Also the food was ready really quick! My wife and myself we got the Connecticut Roll and the Old Fashion New England Mighty! Amazing highly recommend 👌
• KK

  Kevin Konsta

  Sep 27, 2026
  1.0
  New owner of this location. Formerly mystic and they gave 100% more lobster. Just paid $27 for a roll the size of a medium empanada. Do yourself a favor and find another spot. The previous mystic was completely different and a far better value. After the owner response, I must clarify as it was implied, I am in no way a competitor, just a customer that received poor value in comparison to other purveyors.
• JG

  Jackson Grant

  Sep 19, 2026
  5.0
  The best lobster I have had in a while if not tied for the best. Great place to eat if you driving through and if you're local you probably already know. The two woman that served us were so polite and helpful. Can't wait to come back! 10/10
• TO

  Tyna Otero

  Sep 10, 2026
  5.0
  Have been wanting to visit this place for a while. Hubby and I decided our anniversary was the right time. All the reviews were great. It did not disappoint! We had clam chowder and lobster bisque to start. Both were amazing and packed with delicious seafood! Then onto the rolls. Wow! We both had the Connecticut Rolls! Jam packed full of delicious lobster! It was incredible! Abby was our waitress and she was very attentive! Loved toys place and we will be back!