I came here today and NEVER do reviews. First off I ordered everything that I wanted oxtails, chicken, goat , macaroni on the sampler plate.
But let’s get into why there was a problem. First off nobody takes your order, my meal was $60 with a service charge. A guy walked in with a dog that was a friend of bartender / server . I’m an observer at my establishments I wouldn’t allow my employees to openly eat other meals. Never the less cook , touching the dog and I think that is absolutely disgusting! I took pictures they are included and I couldn’t not get a refund. I understand pet friendly , but that shouldn’t be allowed in the kitchen or around the areas you prepare the food, cut lemons ETC
We recently visited Naomi’s Garden expecting a welcoming experience based on the reviews. We approached with smiles and excitement only to be met with very poor customer service and unprofessional attitude.
After asking for an order, the server walked into the back without explaining what was happening, leaving us and other customers standing around in confusion. When I eventually asked for an update on what was going on, an employee sitting down yelled back at us from the back area rather than politely explaining that the kitchen was preparing fresh food.
Basic communication and courtesy are the bare minimum when taking care of customers. Being ignored, left uninformed, and then shouted at when asking a simple question is completely unacceptable. We ultimately chose to leave before purchasing anything. First impressions matter, and we will not be returning or spending our money here.
The is the most honest review ever. The meat from this place is ok . The chicken needs to be cooked a little longer but it's still ok. The peas and rice is the best 🤤 omg it's Sooo good. The plantains were delicious . 🤤 . However, they only give you a little. 🥺I didn't like the collard greens. They taste very bland . I love the bamboo utensils. However, It's too expensive for the food to mediocre. I do feel that with a few adjustments it would be a very successful business. Advice: Cook the chicken longer and add a little more flavor. The collard greens need a lot of help. The pikliz needs to more flavor. The price should match the amount of food and flavor. Don't change the rice . It's excellent 👌
Do not recommend this store. I ordered the jerk chicken meal and it arrived in a small box with baby portions fit for a second grader in elementary school, not worth the $30. I also paid extra for sweet & regular plantations and the stingy restaurant only provided two. Delivery was also delayed almost 2 hours.
RM
Ribs McCartney
Sep 28, 2026
This was great good! We got the sampler with the turkey, fried chicken, Mac and cheese, jerk chicken, pivkeded cabbage, rice and peas, and a side salad, fried plantains, and a key lime pie.
The food is really delicious. Much of it is slow cooked, with authentic and deep, well developed flavors. We especially enjoyed the jerk chicken, and I'd order a full plate of that even!
Eric, the chef, was also serving the food. He was very helpful in offering samples, guiding through the menu with any questions, and stopped by to check in on us often. He's a gem, and you can tell he really cares about the restaurant and the food he serves.
There were also several notable vegetarian options, should you be looking for that, and I'd recommend the jerk jackfruit based on my experience.
We dined in the evening and The atmosphere was very laid back in a good way. Plenty of help from the staff, plenty of seating either inside or outside, and a pleasant dining experience.
I hope I'll have the chance to dine again and I think people should really check out this hidden gem.