Da' Matteo Ristorante Pizzeria

Reviews

• BK

  Bruce Kelly

  Aug 9, 2026
  5.0
  Awesome resturant. Very homey and felt like we were family. Pizza is hot out of the oven and anyway you want it. Wished we lived near Navarre so we could go there more often.
• CV

  Chelsea Vigo

  Aug 6, 2026
  5.0
  Ordered pizza when we arrived vacation. Perfect amount of toooings, perfect crust thickness. Friendly service and super easy pickup.
• DK

  Dan Kennard

  Jul 30, 2026
  4.0
  Fresh ingredients, old school recipes and a lovely brick pizza oven make for a great Italian restaurant. Service is also solid with a good wine list. Has a nice family run vibe.
• JS

  JC Schaller

  Jul 26, 2026
  1.0
  I am not the biggest pizza fan on planet Earth, but my wife is. She could eat the stuff for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. We eat out very rarely, maybe once a week to treat ourselves. So, I was very surprised to see what a twenty-five-dollar pizza looks like from this restaurant. When I say that it felt like one step above Hunt’s Brothers gas station pizza, I am not exaggerating. The toppings, at least for the most part, were natural—real mushrooms and real Italian beef. However, it seemed as if their version of ham was nothing but lunchmeat cut into strips. The pizza sauce was bitter and not very tasty at all. The crust of the pizza was burnt, though the undercarriage was decent. It just seemed like the pizza itself might cost three dollars to make. Bearing in mind that Mary Esther, Florida, is not exactly Destin, Florida, the only other time I have seen pizzas like this is at Disney, where they charge you an arm and a leg for a small pie. It is of very indifferent quality. Do yourselves a favor, stick with Papa John’s or Little Caesars, and save yourself a ton of money. I Bear in mind, not everybody’s experience will be the same! I’ve got a lot of pizza , from around the United States of America. New York Pizza price, West Virginia gas station quality.
• MM

  Mrs. Mac

  Jul 25, 2026
  1.0
  I DO NOT RECOMMEND! Tried to come here to eat, both my daughter & I called to inquire about food allergies/GF options & was told to bug off & no. I spoke to Jocelyn who refused to get the Manager, when I politely said that I needed help, she came back and told me that the manager refused to come out and talk to me. Waste a trip, no service and they don’t care about locals.

Frequently Asked Questions About Da' Matteo Ristorante Pizzeria