Da' Matteo Ristorante Pizzeria

Reviews

• EE

  EnRiQuEe

  4 days ago
  5.0
  So good it doesn't even make sense. The balsamic glaze they serve with the bread is crazy good. Pro-tip: have them add the balsamic glaze to the prosciutto and mushroom, white sauce pizza. 11/10.
• SL

  Susan Leveille

  May 12, 2026
  5.0
  Da Matteo has been recommended by several friends and we finally tried it… and were blown away!! We were there on a rainy afternoon recently and the nice fire burning in the brick pizza oven was very cheery. Our server was genuinely friendly and attentive and immediately brought us fresh, delicious bread and dipping oil with a balsamic drizzle. When the food arrived I was delighted. My gnocchi with pesto was served in a perfectly baked bread bowl! My friend had eggplant parm and although it was considered an antipasto it was really a full meal. We loved every bit of everything. A gem right here in Navarre! I really enjoy supporting local restaurants that are not chains. Da Matteo is fantastic!
• BB

  Brittany Buring

  May 9, 2026
  5.0
  It was incredible. The spaghetti carbonara was so flavorful, the pizza was delicious, and the desert was awesome. The espresso was also really good. I could've made a meal out of the free bread and olive oil. (And for the kiddos [or adults, no shame] the pizza with fries and sausage [which is more similar to hotdogs than italian sausage] on top was actually really good!) This is a pretty great place for some authentic Italian food. The atmosphere was nice and the service was great as well. If I wasn't only visiting for Mother's day I would absolutely be coming back regularly. I'll definitely be going back whenever I visit town! (Apologies, I only have the photo of the pizza with fries and sausage)
• JM

  Johana Marie

  May 2, 2026
  5.0
  They made my daughters first birthday one to remember. They sang happy birthday to her and made us feel so special. Thank you once again! Food was AMAZING, the wine nice and fresh and the beers cold as can be! Would highly recommend this place.
• PP

  Pikayla

  Apr 23, 2026
  5.0
  Delicious pizza. Italian style thin crust with just the right amount of high quality toppings. I'm from the Northeast where good Italian food is a staple and has been hard to find here in Florida. This is not only a must but it's on my very short list of go to places. And the service is excellent to boot! It's a utilitarian atmosphere just rows of tables. Not a deal breaker but worth mentioning to set expectations. I'll definitely be back again and again!

Frequently Asked Questions About Da' Matteo Ristorante Pizzeria