Mahina

Reviews

• MP

  Mary Ann Priore

  4 days ago
  2.0
  So very disappointed in our dinner here. My adult children tried to plan a very special anniversary dinner for us and when we arrived at this beautiful Property, they were immediately so excited. That excitement dissipated instantly as we were read by very unenthusiastic staff. From the hostess to the bus boys to our waitress, everyone had absolutely no energy. We sat on the beautiful patio enjoy enjoying a gorgeous night and we were so disappointed in the food. Both gentlemen ordered steaks, medium rare, and they both came out way overdone. When we finally got someone’s attention to take them back. They waited approximately 10 minutes to get new steaks, which we’re done exactly the same And for a different cut than a ribeye, which was on the menu. They weren’t even fully plated properly.. We finally got a manager to come over who only apologized and said we’ll take them off the bill. There was no effort to offer anything else or do anything for us. The night ended so poorly our waitress never acknowledged our anniversary and we left very very disappointed. I’m just warning you that if you go here with high hopes, you will be disappointed.
• JD

  Josette DiBlasio

  May 13, 2026
  5.0
  Had an amazing dinner at Mahina at Isla Bella Resort. We were able to get a sunset reservation outside on the beach just hours before and the view was absolutely breathtaking. The food was delicious and the whole experience felt like we were transported to a different country. Such a beautiful atmosphere and a perfect dinner experience. Highly recommend and we will be back!
• CC

  coveredbigrace

  May 4, 2026
  5.0
  Staying at Isla Bella to celebrate our 30th anniversary. Had a wonderful dinner at the resort’s restaurant, Mahina. A sunset reservation time made for a spectacular view throughout our meal. The food was fabulous and our server, Jess, was attentive, kind, and friendly. Her service was the “icing-on-cake” to a memorable and enjoyable experience.
• ST

  Sami Teittinen

  May 4, 2026
  5.0
  Isla Bella resort area, where Mahia is located, (even the drive in) is beautiful. The restaurant itself is by the water and while the dining area is a bit sterile and lighting is too bright, the outdoor seating is gorgeous. We ended up sitting at the Mahina cocktail bar this time which is inside. Great choice! Kyle, the bar tender was fantastic. Although the bar and restaurant was busy, he was attentive, very friendly and made great cocktails. For dinner the Mahi and Ahi Tuna were very good. We will be back!
• JT

  John Timothy

  May 2, 2026
  5.0
  The food here was absolutely amazing. On my first visit, I had the fish with sautéed vegetables and jasmine coconut rice, and it was so good that I had to come back the very next night. That second visit did not disappoint—I ordered the short ribs with the same sides, and it was just as incredible. I’m not usually a big vegetable person, but this place completely changed my mind. The vegetables were cooked to perfection—flavorful, well-seasoned, and honestly some of the best I’ve ever had. I could have easily made a meal out of just those. If I’m ever back in the Keys, this will be my go-to dinner spot without a doubt. It’s absolutely worth the visit.