Mike's Pizza and Pub

Reviews

• TW

  Trudi Wood

  1 day ago
  4.0
  Best pizza in town, IMHO! Our families fave!! So, we tried a couple of hoagies. Italian sausage was super good and messy. Sauce was hot and perfectly thick and spicy, sausage full of flavor, peppers and onions cooked perfectly. I loved it. The roll was exceptionally crispy and delicious. Cheese steak was just okay. Hubby was unimpressed.
• SM

  Sarah Markovich

  4 days ago
  5.0
  We are in town once a year, and Mike's is on our must visit list every time! Great food, great prices, great staff, great atmosphere! They are one of the best in the area. Gluten free option for pizza, too, which is a bonus!
• JM

  Jeff Morand

  Aug 2, 2026
  2.0
  Got wings, pizza and cheesy bread. Everything was subpar. Wings were a bad version of buffalo wild wings. Pizza crust was bland, sauce was bland. I don't like doing chain places on vacation but they would have been better than this place.
• JV

  Jannette Velez

  Jul 26, 2026
  2.0
  Good comment, The waiter was nice and attentive. However, Spent about $100 and Fresh fries were not crunchy, they went in too early and soaked up oil. The steak skillet was super salty unable to be eaten. The taste of the mozzarella sticks was weird. & the poppers were not popping. The jalapeños was sooo hard to bite through. Ordered Wings to go , we hope they good. The inside lights were surging. Cute little place, w 16 TVs and like 25 light fixtures! 😳 Not the best time experience.
• ZS

  Zach Storm

  Jul 15, 2026
  2.0
  As we entered we were told to seat ourselves wherever we liked, but most of the tables still had remnants of the last customers that had visited, so while the place was not crowded, it seemed like seating was somewhat limited. We ordered a side of garlic knots based on many reviews mentioning them, and we're instantly disappointed. Thought they'd be smaller but they're basically buttered dinner rolls with garlic glaze & were served with a very watered down pizza sauce. We also ordered the chips & salsa & the chips had a strange, almost chemical taste to them. The stromboli was just ok (overloaded w/pepperoni & not enough of the other ingredients). Our server was Abby, and she was pleasant & attentive, but that was the best thing about the place. Overall, we were all unhappy with the food and ended up leaving most of it uneaten & still somewhat hungry. Very doubtful that we would 'roll the dice' on this place again. I see these 5☆ reviews & think, these must be from locals or people affiliated w/the establishment or maybe we came in on a night where the staff wasn't firing on all cylinders, either way, you only get 1 shot at a first impression & this was a fail Mike's Pizza.