I loved the clams with angel hair pasta, French onion soup, and duck!
You can see my full review and what I ordered on tik tok @quiccle
BA
BCBA Author
Jun 11, 2026
Hands down the best fine dining in Key West. Prices are reasonable and this may be the best duck have had in Florida; period. Cesar salad and lobster bisque are must orders apps along with angels on horseback. Can’t recommend highly enough!
AT
Angela Taury
Jun 1, 2026
Five stars. No notes. Everything was absolute fire. Awesome service, excellent food, wine and dessert. We both had the hogfish snapper. Key lime pie is the best around, hands down. Highly recommend!!
DS
Diana Maite Shane
May 31, 2026
The Hog fish was so delicately prepared. It melted in our mouths! Would come back here 100%. Check hours even if booked on Open Table as their hours change and we booked but they were actually closed but they honored the reservation and treated us very well. Thank you for the high end treatment despite the situation.
MW
Mark Walker
May 31, 2026
This Old Town standby is excellence itself in both food and service. We sat next to two couples who come down every year and eat here. I had the hog fish special with rice, shredded carrots, and lima beans, which was the single best meal of the trip—based on my friends’ recommendations. Of course, I had to plunk for the Key Lime pie with toasted marshmallow topping and meringue on the side with fruit. This place isn’t cheap, but boy is it special.