Goodfellas Pizza Jacksonville

Reviews

• BY

  Birdy Love's you

  May 6, 2026
  5.0
  This was my first time eating from here and it was delicious! I had the jerk chicken pizza and hot honey lemon wings. I was greeted fast once I walked in and my food was fresh. I will definitely will be back to try some other items on the menu.
• MR

  Mmms Rodall

  May 3, 2026
  1.0
  There customer service is horrible I order online for pickup and I came in to get my order just to be told by a rude young lady “a white man pick it up” “but I can take down your number and let my manger know about this issue” just to never hear from nobody. I called days later same rude lady answers and I tried to example the issue she hung up. I just laughed and went bout my day. Hiring good people & great customer service matters because it keeps the business flourishing!!
• JB

  James Black

  May 1, 2026
  2.0
  40 dollars for two Philly cheese steak combos what's five ways in a drink it was fresh but fries were burnt wings were not the flavors that I ordered 🫠 I wasn't busy I was only customer jus wasn't what I expected well try again
• WE

  Wayne Elliott

  Apr 17, 2026
  5.0
  When it comes to late night options, this restaurant has been a game changer! Not only are they open late, but their pizzas are some of the best I have ever had. I highly recommend the Jerk Chicken Pizza which is something you will not find anywhere else!
• HM

  h miles

  Apr 12, 2026
  1.0
  This place has gone down. They used to have AWESOME rasta pasta, unfortunately even though it's still on the menu they don't sell it anymore. I placed an order here tonight (thru a 3rd party app) and because the person who cooked the rasta pasta doesn't work there anymore I had to substitute it for some wings. (Blah) I bought the meal that came with fries. The wings were NOT good, they didn't give me my fries and they DO NOT protect your food (by tying your bag in a knot or taping it closed) when you call they purposely don't answer the phone. This business is mediocre at best (without the rasta pasta) and the customer service is seriously lacking.

Frequently Asked Questions About Goodfellas Pizza Jacksonville