Main St Pizza & Ice Cream

Reviews

• AA

  Anna

  3 days ago
  1.0
  Ordered ahead of time and it said to pick up by a certain time, which was 30 minutes after placing the order. Got there and still had to wait for another 20 minutes. The purpose for doing pick up is for it to be quick. The app wasn't any help since it told us to pick up by the certain time and it wasnt ready. Frustrating when being told it's because of cold spots in the oven. I've gotten food here before, chicken wings weren't crispy. Ice cream was alright, price seemed high. Hopefully this pizza is good because we spent a good amount of money on it.
• KB

  Kent Bailey

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Amazing food. We come here offer and usually order ahead. This time we came up and ordered on the fly and it only took 10-15 minutes. The meatlovers pizza and add honey hot sauce is AWESOME.
• EE

  explodingcatbutslime

  5 days ago
  3.0
  The food was very yummy, but the wait was quite long. The 2 slices of pizza was 13 DOLLARS?? Just get a pizza from domino's or little ceasers!! After that, I went to go get some ice cream which was engraved into the side of the restaurant, which was kinda cool. Upon looking at the flavors, they didn't have the one I wanted (of course) and had to go with Moose Tracks. The price was 8 DOLLARS FOR 1 SMALL CUP??? The food itself is top notch, but the amount of people, service, and especially prices don't make it worth it. I wouldn't go again, but they do have some good ice cream. 3/5 stars.
• JR

  Julie Ann Rivera

  May 9, 2026
  5.0
  Don’t let the small size fool you — this local pizza spot serves some of the best pizza around! OMG! No liquor license [UGGH], just genuinely amazing pizza made right. The crust was perfect, the ingredients tasted fresh, and everything came out hot and full of flavor. It has that true neighborhood pizza joint feel where the focus is completely on the food. Definitely the kind of place you find once and keep coming back to! And we are coming back!!
• MG

  Michele Geiger

  May 3, 2026
  5.0
  Realllly cute place. Outdoor covered seating with fans. The food was really good and loved the garlic knots. The stromboli was a great size and delicious. Drinks were canned. Ice cream right there but didn't try it. The staff was super nice and only reason not 5 stars is because they didn't have enough people working so the food wait was longer and people had to wait 15 min for ice cream because there was one girl doing both sides. In spite of that she was very sweet and professional, not her fault. The wait was worth it. Street parking but wasn't difficult.