Mario's Meat Market and Deli

Reviews

• RR

  RavenDarkClaw

  May 13, 2026
  5.0
  Unbelievable. NY city is in Fort Myers. Unparalleled beauty, everything your looking for from the old world. Meats, cheeses, produce, pasta, olives, peppers, broccoli rabe, ready to order sandwiches, hot peppers, olive oil, dried sausages, herbs, spices and more. Everything made fresh ready to go. High quality bread. Just like home...Five Stars!
• DP

  Darth Fader Productions

  May 13, 2026
  5.0
  As someone from Long Island who very much misses a real Italian deli this is the place to be if you're anywhere here in Southwest Florida. I'm sad I live an hour away from here. Their Sandwich prices are amazing better than Publix better ingredients. All their fresh deli food is amazing and it's just an awesome place if you love Italian food or you're in Italian or you from New York this is a little bit of home and everything you need to make your Italian meals or enjoy something already made
• PP

  Pamella

  May 11, 2026
  5.0
  Love love love the store but a word of advice...... I bought some antipasto salad the other day and went to eat it. When I opened the container, I noticed what looked to be a nut off some sort. (I have a SEVERE ALL NUT ALLERGY) so I called store and was advised that there was Mortadella in the salad which has pistachios in the meat. LUCKILY I noticed this and didn't eat any and called the store. I WOULD HIGHLY ADVISE TO LIST ALLERGENS ON FOODS THAT CONTAIN NUTS (and possibly dairy, eggs, etc) . I would never take legal action had I had an reaction or worse, BUT some other person may. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE LIST NUTS when they are in your food. I will still frequent your store but with more caution. ⚠️
• JJ

  Jessi

  May 10, 2026
  5.0
  Had magnificent Filet Mignons for Mother's Day. Pulled them off the grill with an internal temperature of 130°. Could have even done 125°. Butter-tender, melt in your mouth, delicious piece of meat! One of the Butchers, Mike, was polite, helpful, having fun with us, & answered our couple questions. Also, purchased a "meat pinwheel" that was rich and so delicious. Definitely would recommend them!
• JS

  John Shea

  May 5, 2026
  5.0
  The best Italian deli around.I just won't go in season because it's to crowded. They have to much to list but everything is awesome. The antipasto and hot peppers stuffed with cheese and bashuto is worth the 45 minutes ride plus all the pasta dishes you can heat up at home. For an Irish kid I get all excited just walking in the door and smelling everything 👍