US 17 NY Deli

Reviews

• CH

  Cody Hosang

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Dont miss out on this place! We got a "Wall Street" which is Pastrami, Swiss, and Mustard. A Tuna Salad sub and an Egg Salad sub. And wow. The quality is impressive! My Pastrami was absolutely delicious. Some of the most flavorful ive had. And the Egg salad was easily the best ive had. The protein portions on all the sandwiches were very generous. The sandwiches were nearly overflowing with toppings and deliciousness. Oh and the Tuna Salad, my wife nearly inhaled it. She said the quality of Tuna was higher than most sandwich places. All of the veggies were crisp and fresh. One last thing. *PRO TIP* Get the Canoli. Get 2. Hell, get 10. Theyre filled fresh and the shell has the crunch you dream about. Literally the best sub sandwiches we've had in years. The portions are generous, everythings delicious, and its an excellent bang for your buck! Stop reading and order already. You'll thank me later.
• TH

  Theresa Halliwell

  4 days ago
  5.0
  This restaurant is AMAZING and absolutely worth the drive from Macclenny, FL! The NY Reuben was OMG delicious! 😋 The ladies were so friendly and informative, and I love that everything is made in-house. And don’t forget to save room for your sweet tooth—ice cream, cheesecake, and key lime pie! 🍦🍰🥧 Highly recommend! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
• CP

  Chelsea Pemberton

  4 days ago
  5.0
  My mom brought me half her Pastrami she got this afternoon. Pretty good sandwich. If anything it was too much meat (not a complaint!!! That puppy was just stacked. UP. Meat and bread were good. Will deff be back to try other items or just get the pastrami again. Worth a shot. I appreciate the variety and having something different in the area.
• SS

  Samy Smith

  Aug 8, 2026
  5.0
  We have found our deli! I had the Cuban deluxe and my husband had the Reuben. My sandwich was flavorful and the hubby says his Reuben was the best he has had in the greater JAX area. I also had the French Onion soup…it was rich and delicious. Fantastic value for the portion size. Staff was friendly and the restaurant is very clean. We will be back!
• ML

  Melissa Lisiecki

  Aug 8, 2026
  1.0
  My daughter was craving a salmon and lox bagel, so we decided to try this place. I have lots of dietary restrictions, so I was hesitant to give them a try. The atmosphere is nice, I’m from NJ and it definitely has a NY deli feel. I walk up to the counter and I’m met with an emotionless young man. The dreaded monotone voice and Gen Z stare. I asked if they had any gluten free bread and he mumbles “yes”. No further information, no nothing. After an uncomfortable stare down I had to ask, what kind of gluten free bread do you have? Are they bagels, buns, sandwich bread? He answers sandwich bread then proceeds to look completely miserable as I finish my order. Not a great first impression. A friendly woman walks in, greets me, then goes to the back. Shortly after I hear some sort of dispute between them. She later comes out and informs me that the gluten free bread they have went bad, so she offers to make me eggs and bacon. It is what it is, I appreciated her effort to help. She then proceeds to tell off the other employees, calling them lazy for not making sure they had items in stock. It was so awkward. I understand having these conversations with your employees, but not in front of the customers! It was so uncomfortable. I finally get my food. My daughter starts eating her bagel and immediately says it tastes funny. I look at her bagel and the salmon is discolored and smells bad. I open up my food and it’s a small amount of super dry scrambled eggs and 2 strips of paper thin soggy bacon. $20 for inedible food. I should have gone back or called, but after that awkward experience, I just didn’t want to go back. I never leave bad reviews, I just don’t go back, but this was such a bad experience. I think about it every time I drive past. I wanted so badly to like this place, I miss the amazing delis in NJ, but this place wasn’t it.