SG
Siris Goldenhart
Jul 2, 2026
We ordered a large BYO pizza for pick up, so I can't comment on the service or atmosphere.
I will also note that we are vegan, so we ordered vegan cheese and perhaps the chefs were unfamiliar with it.
I cannot, however, make any excuses for the massive, uncut garlic cloves or the paper-thin pizza dough. When we picked up a slice it collapsed under the weight of the toppings and everything just slid off into the box. We scooped and ate, but the enormous garlic cloves were truly off-putting.
We would not order pizza from here again.
I also ordered fries and requested ketchup, but that was either forgotten or simply left off.
First time here since changing ownership from Atlantic Social. My husband and I shared an app and the hot honey pepperoni pizza. The pepperonis were my favorite - the small kind that curl up when heated! Everything was very tasty and priced reasonably. Our server Kyler was very attentive and personable. We will definitely be back!
ordered a cheese pizza and they gave us tomato bread💀 absolutely no cheese on our cheese pizza.. and the tomato sauce was just a bunch of tomato chunks, we laughed about it but it was to hide how upset we were.. after a long day at the beach this is what we ate unfortunately.. 💔
TK
Theresa Konteh
Jun 27, 2026
We took a chance and ordered from Soho Pizza yesterday, and we are glad we did as we went back for the second time in two days. The food was succulent and the customer service was exceptional. I will be back. Please try the wings( spicy honey garlic), Smoking Soho Pizza and the Soho Penne....all delicious and thank me later:)
CK
Caitlin Kratz
Jun 23, 2026
I screwed up on my own order that I made online and apologized, and admitted fault for my mistake. The manager was so kind to have my order fixed free of charge, that was EXTREMELY kind and generous. I’ve been here many times all of the employees and staff are so generous and kind and their pizza is the BEST pizza in Rehoboth Beach, DE. My wife and I have never had a bad meal here and we always make a stop at Soho Slice when visiting my Mom that lives around the corner and frequents there herself. I definitely recommend you give this place a try when coming to Rehoboth Beach!