We're Back Pizza

Reviews

• ML

  Matthew Lee

  May 11, 2026
  5.0
  An absolutely underrated pizza spot coming from a pizza snob. May not be considered an authentic New Haven style, but the food is very much above average compared to other pizza places. Needed to add my 2 cents here because this place doesn't seem to get enough love.
• MM

  Mike Merna

  May 8, 2026
  5.0
  I put in a large order for our crew to test the quality of their product, ordering several pizzas ( Margherita, plain, gramma, Sicilian, Lasagna, We're Back Special, Bakery Style Sicilian ) salads, wraps as well as garlic knots. Everything was on point, as well as Mike the owner delivered the pizza himself. Mike is really a nice guy who've I've seen on Tik Tok make all kinds of videos claiming to be the Sicilian Capital of CT. He talks up his food but he also backs it up with his love for making his food. We could tell the passion he has for his business as well as making sure his customers are happy with everything. Mike texted me the following day to follow up and make sure we were satisfied with the food and service. I am definitely going to be a repeat customer as he does backup everything he claims about his food. We had 10+ employees in which several brought food home to share with their families. We have ordered pizzeria food from other well known CT pizzerias and most of the time my people pass on sharing it with their families. Mike left a great impression with us and in turn the least I could do was go out of my way to give his business the props that they deserve. Thanks again to We're Back and Mike for a very positive experience.
• JB

  Jason Bernard

  Apr 26, 2026
  5.0
  Saw this place on TikTok so we stopped in and food was great staff super friendly
• JH

  J. Kevin H

  Apr 23, 2026
  5.0
  Quality, thin crust pizza. Very good. Abundant toppings. Highly recommended.
• DD

  Dawn Decoteau

  Apr 17, 2026
  5.0
  We placed an order for 35 pizzas with very little notice and We're Back Pizza delivered at lunchtime on time and delicious!