We had delivery. What was good: crust was nice, a good mix of chewy and crispy. Delivery original time was 79 minutes came in just under an hour.
But...... this pizza is WAY too sweet. We tried pepperoni, the Blanco and the red Margartia. Oof, I couldnt taste the flavors because the sauce and crust were so over sweetened. Try someone else.
Our favorite Italian food in Parker. Family friendly and great pizza and Italian dishes.
Okay Midwest pizza, but I wouldn’t call it authentic “New York style”. As someone who grew up in New York, the first thing I noticed was the crust. The crust wasn’t stretched thin enough, and the dough was bland and overly chewy, making me think it either wasn’t rested long enough or wasn’t developed properly. The sauce was okay, and the cheese had good flavor, although it was a little greasy. Even the pizzeria itself didn’t have the feel of a classic New York pizza shop, which added to the disconnect. Overall, it wasn’t a bad pizza, but it definitely didn’t live up to the “New York-style” claim. I probably wouldn’t order from here again.
SF
Sharon Fontenot
Jul 25, 2026
Colonna’s Pizza is the Best in Parker! If you haven’t tried the Lasagna yet…You should! It’s the best I’ve ever had!!! Augustine and his staff are all so kind and happy! The atmosphere is fun and homey!
Colonna’s has the best pizza I have ever had. I’ve had Joe’s in New York and while it’s a great slice of pizza, Colonna’s is better. I ordered it for my mom and she told me it was the best pizza she had ever had in her life. This pizza joint is a gem. I haven’t had too many other things from the menu other than the wings, but the pizza stands out as exceptional.