Gelato & aMore

Reviews

• EE

  Ellie

  4 days ago
  5.0
  What a wonderful place to chill and relax while enjoying some tasty treats! Anna is absolutely amazing! I recommend!
• MH

  Michelle Hurni

  6 days ago
  5.0
  Above and beyond! Great pasta, and of course the gelato is amazing. My grandkids said the pasta and meatballs were "delicious."
• LJ

  Lisa Johnson

  Aug 3, 2026
  5.0
  The gelato was excellent. We ended up ordering bigger cups, so it was a lot to eat!! Very delicious and in a great location.
• DH

  Danny Hesser

  Jul 31, 2026
  4.0
  Veggie supreme, Giardiniera, continues to be a great go-to meal for us. Ordered for take out with 1 hour delay so I could go for a walk around the park. The garlic bread needs more garlic, however! Folks are always nice and helpful there.
• DZ

  Dennis Zoss

  Jul 10, 2026
  4.0
  One star because there is nothing that can raise this higher based on the food we just had. The eggplant hoagie was on soft bread with what seemed to be somehow breaded boiled eggplant. What resulted was a mushy, flavorless mess. The polenta with whatever sauce we chose couldn't matter less. The sauce had scant flavor and if you like the taste of hot water with some texture this is the dish for you. Seriously, I'm not trying to be mean or vindictive since we got a partial refund, this was the worst meal I have had in Fort Collins in the 30 years I've been here. It's so difficult to understand what happened here because when I see all of these 5 star ratings, I just trust that these people are speaking there minds truthfully, as am I. EDIT: Paul and I had a good conversation about what went wrong this night and there is nothing more a person could ask than how this has been made a much better experience. I appreciate that Paul is passionate about his restaurant and maybe a little bit exuberant on some of his other responses. For myself, I look forward to trying this restaurant again soon. Thank you Paul and staff