Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• JT

  Jean Toal

  Sep 26, 2026
  5.0
  I had to call the store to fix my order because I hit send too soon when ordering online. Sophia, who answered the phone, defined what true customer service should be! She was so kind, patient & sweet! I was very impressed with the way she handled the situation!
• SS

  spencer strand

  Sep 24, 2026
  2.0
  Beware paying in cash...delivery people spoke very little English or at least pretended not too, two people not one, didnt have any change until I started to call store...suddenly had just enough change to net them 28% tip, pretty clever really.
• CH

  Cole Holmes

  Sep 20, 2026
  5.0
  I ordered the 6.99 pairings medium pizza and wings. Pizza was perfect, wings were perfect. There was a small mix-up with my order, but the manager Qiona took care of if before i needed to even explain much. She identified the issue immediately and made it more than better. I will definitely be ordering again. Even on sunday football day, my order was corrected and delivered well within 30 minutes.
• LM

  Lawrence Martinez

  Sep 14, 2026
  2.0
  I ordered a Philly steak cheese sandwich. All bread no meat. My pizza New York style looked like a frozen pizza
• DD

  Debbie

  Aug 12, 2026
  5.0
  Everybody should order from this location!!! After so many troubling issues this location finally has a new leader, and her name is Kaitlyn. If I spelled it wrong girl, I totally apologize. She has made all of the difference that we all have been looking for. I can see without a doubt as a local business owner of 36 years that this is now the top number one Papa John’s location in Colorado. They could not have done it without Kaitlyn. She is experienced. She has a good business head on her shoulders. She knows how to make a difference let me rephrase that she is the difference in pizza here locally. So many places get it wrong. So many places have gotten it wrong and and continually get it wrong.. This is THE number one location. This is a location to pay attention to.. EVERYTHING TO DO WITH THIS LOCATION MATTERS TO KAITLYN. Every phone call every order every delivery, every crust, every topping … Every everything matters. This is a girl to look out for because not only is she going to own a location one day she is going to own multiple locations. Kaitlyn IS The difference we have all been needing so badly in this day and age of crappy leadership, crappy employees, and food that is disappointing. She is bringing and breathing life back into this Papa John’s location that has been lacking for a long time. I stopped ordering from here over two years ago. After meeting Kaitlyn and seeing the quality of the product that she lets leave her facility, I will never ever again buy, or order from anywhere else. You did it, Kaitlyn you won me over.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza