Pizza 72

Reviews

• MT

  Melissa Thompson

  4 days ago
  5.0
  I love the pizza here! It is where I always buy my pizza. I order it "light on the cheese" just because that is my personal preference, and it comes out with what I believe is the perfect balance of toppings! Carry out is the only way I have ever purchased it, so the atmosphere doesn't matter to me and that is why I didn't rate that. I have never seen anyone eating in the restaurant. That is not who they cater to, but there is some seating available. I highly recommend Pizza 72 for great tasting pizza!
• NW

  Nicolle Wyatt

  May 11, 2026
  1.0
  Gas station pizza is better than this pizza. The best part about it was the cheese.
• AS

  Auston Smith

  May 5, 2026
  4.0
  This place was a little underwhelming at first but after getting my order in I sat down and kind of enjoyed the quiet. My food came out fast and hot! Very happy with my pizza and stoked about the garlic rolls!! The QR menus aren’t my favorite but everyone is using them now so not really a complaint just an observation. Overall I will be coming back here again!!
• AD

  A “Ajwildt” D

  May 1, 2026
  5.0
  If you’re chasing that classic New York–style slice in Aurora, Pizza 72 absolutely deserves a spot in your rotation. The first thing that stands out is the crust— crisp on the bottom with just enough chew to hold structure without flopping. It’s got that balance you want: a little crunch, a little elasticity, and it actually supports the toppings instead of collapsing under them. You can tell the dough is handled right. The sauce leans toward a fresh, slightly sweet tomato profile, which pairs well with the cheese without overpowering it. Pizza 72 is a legit go-to for NY-style pizza in Aurora—consistent, and satisfying!
• CS

  Cody S

  Apr 30, 2026
  3.0
  Decor feels half done. Thursday lunchtime, grabbed 2 slices. Didn't have any pepperoni slices available, had to add them onto the cheese slices. Wish this pizza had WAY more flavor. Compared to other pizza places, I would rather drive a little further to other places then this one. Their recipe needs serious TLC.

Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza 72