Mastro's City Hall

Reviews

• MF

  Mikela F

  4 days ago
  2.0
  Went to Mastro’s for my birthday dinner. The service was incredible, unfortunately the food was not . The scallops that I ordered were VERY mushy, which tells me they are undercooked or prepared in an over crowded pan. There was also little to no flavor. Along with the sautéed spinach, bland…. Not impressed at all. :( The ambience is dim lit with an unbearable noise level that you can’t hear the person next to you, there is an overcrowding of tables in this place , which allows for so many people in the space. Makes for a chaotic date or intimate night of yelling across the table . The service from kind waiters/ waitresses, bussers and food runners were an A+
• MP

  Mary P

  Aug 25, 2026
  5.0
  Attended an event at Maestro's City Hall. Very nice place, Sophia Humbert who had competed on American Idol was playing the piano and singing. The food was excellent as well as the service. Highly recommend!
• RB

  Ryne Burgess

  Aug 23, 2026
  5.0
  Everything was amazing! Andres was an incredible server and we will definitely be back!
• TG

  T Garcia

  Aug 22, 2026
  5.0
  Came for my birthday dinner and got a amazing 5 star food and service experience that I wont forget! Best food I've ever had. Tomahawk steak, lobster mashed potatoes and Wild Mushroom & Black Truffle Gnocchi. Plus a very delicious butter cake. Can't wait to go back and keep trying the rest of the menu . A big plus was the Ambience and great Performance of the lounge singers!
• EK

  Ethan Koslow

  Jul 28, 2026
  5.0
  If you are looking for a dining experience that dials up high-octane luxury and classic steakhouse indulgence to eleven, Mastro’s City Hall Steakhouse delivers in full force. Known for its sultry lighting, high-energy atmosphere, and top-tier cuts of beef, this spot remains a true titan of upscale dining. From the moment you step through the doors, City Hall sets a sophisticated, glamorous tone. The dining room features dark woods, plush seating, and low, dramatic lighting that gives the space an intimate yet buzzing feel. The live piano bar adds an extra layer of timeless charm, making it a favorite for everything from celebratory dinners to high-powered business meetings. The culinary performance starts strong with iconic appetizers like the Chilled Seafood Tower, which arrives billowing with dry-ice smoke and packed with fresh lobster, king crab, and oysters. The main event, however, is the steak. Mastro’s serves their prime cuts—like the incredibly tender Bone-in Ribeye and Filet Mignon—on sizzling 400°F plates coated in bubbling butter. Pairing these with massive, shareable sides like the rich Lobster Mashed Potatoes creates an unforgettable meal. To round out the night, ordering the legendary Warm Butter Cake is essentially mandatory. Crispy on the edges, warm and gooey in the center, and topped with vanilla ice cream, it easily seals the deal. Accompanied by polished, white-glove service that feels attentive rather than stiff, City Hall justifies its high-end price tag by turning a simple dinner into a genuine event.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mastro's City Hall