Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• GW

  Gene Walker

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Great food
• CO

  Chris Jackson (onyxronin)

  Oct 3, 2026
  5.0
  First time visit got two pies and they were beautiful and delicious. Haven't had a pizza with that much cheese pull in a while.
• JL

  Joe Leggett

  Sep 21, 2026
  1.0
  It’s advertised as New York style pizza, so I brought my girlfriend that’s from New Jersey. The wait staff wasn’t friendly, not rude, but not friendly. One sat at a table with some other people and was vaping. Ordered 3 slices of Pizza. Tasted bland and like it had been sitting out and reheated. Server asked us how we liked it and I said it wasn’t great. She said that no one likes the slices, but the whole pies were better…..that would have been good info when I ordered. For a Saturday night this place was dead. I had high expectations going in for a first time visit. I was really hoping to take my girlfriend a good pizza spot because she had been asking. I will try a new place next weekend.
• MH

  M L H

  Jul 16, 2026
  5.0
  Always ask for Gwen- she is hilarious!! Best pizza by a mile!!! Nothing in the Birmingham area beats it. I always want to try other things on the menu but the pizza is THAT good!!!!
• MM

  Margaret

  Jul 8, 2026
  1.0
  A few months ago we went in at a somewhat off time. A man I assume was the owner sat at the bar working. Looked over at us a few times and never acknowledged us. We got up and left Today we tried once again and they were busy at lunch. We waited over an hour for a pizza and NEVER got it again we got up and left. The waiter kept giving us 5 more minute garbage. Needless to say we won't try a third time.