Gabriella's

Reviews

• AB

  Ashley Benson

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Absolutely the best Italian restaurant on SPI! We were staying at a nearby resort and decided to try Gabriella’s. From the outside it looks like a cute restaurant but it doesn’t do it justice, such a pretty restaurant inside. My husband and I ordered the spaghetti festival and the ravioli dinner. Both were AMAZING! We also really enjoyed the provided bread as an appetizer. Our server Henry was a great host! Constantly kept our drinks full, was very personable, and very polite. Definitely recommend going at the beginning of your vacation so you can go multiple times! ;)
• RR

  Ryan

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Where do I start! We were greeted by an amazing hostess, and sat extremely quickly. Such an amazing drink selection for the Kids and an EXTENSIVE bar menu for the adults (TRY THE SANGRIA) . The appetizers were beyond compare, the Spinach artichoke dip, and the Bruschetta were to DIE FOR! I had the Pasta Al Tonno, Full of flavor, spicy, savory. Everything I love in pasta. My wife had the Five layer Lasagna, they were not lying when they said HOME MADE, you can really taste the love in the food and in the service. Purely recommendations from our wonderful server. We ended our night with the Banana Creme Cheese Cake. WOW. Truly remarkable. Cannot see myself going to another establishment and having such a great experience. 10/10
• JS

  Jeremy Sharp

  Feb 26, 2026
  5.0
  Best Italian on SPI in my opinion! This is my second visit to the restaurant, and was just as good as I remembered from my first visit 7 years ago. Food is excellent. Service is great. Atmosphere is very cool. Started with calamari for an appetizer, then "the Sicilian" pizza. Both were super tasty. Everyone I was dining with enjoyed their selections as well. We finished off the meal with tiramisu and cannoli to share with the whole table. 10/10, highly recommend!
• BG

  Bryan G

  Feb 23, 2026
  1.0
  So incredibly disappointed. I ordered take out for four. I arrived 10 minutes after I ordered and my order was already bagged, not fresh at all. Kids buttered noodles were so small I would have barely been able to feed my toddler. I asked if they would add noodles to the small container and they said they could add another kids pasta for $11. $11 for a quarter cup, wow. We finally agreed to fill the container for $4. I then asked for their coupon special of a free dessert. Manager said it's dine in only. Coupon did not specify dine in only. I said he was being inflexible and he said I was the one being inflexible. Huh? He was happy to forgo our $80 bill over honoring the free cake coupon. Nice management skills. A slice of cake costs about a dollar, max. Once home we found our $24 Manicotti was barely enough for a child. Again, so incredibly disappointed! Will not be back and we are a large group that comes annually. Your loss, Russo's gain.
• MK

  mary kosanke

  Feb 22, 2026
  4.0
  Food was delicious! Our waiter was good. We tried to use the coupon in the spi book which clearly states free appetizer or dessert with 2 entrees. Some restrictions apply. We had 2 couples at our table and were splitting our bill. Our waiter was aware we were using coupons for our appetizers. At the end of the meal, the waiter told us the coupons were one per table. We asked to speak with the manager and he said so sad too bad, one per table even though we had 2 separate checks. We won't be back. Our friends who winter here for 2 months won't be back. Their friends won't be back! Just beware!!!

Frequently Asked Questions About Gabriella's